Critical accounting research (CAR) has long articulated emancipatory ambitions, yet debates continue regarding how such ambitions can translate into meaningful forms of ’impact’. Existing debates typically frame this challenge either as an issue of research design (balancing rigour and relevance through immersion or distance) or as a matter of paradigmatic positioning (critical or not). Drawing on insights from an interdisciplinary workshop panel, this paper argues that such framings neglect the ethical and normative challenges of immersion itself. Meaningful change through CAR is not merely a question of ontological stance or degree of immersion in a research setting. Rather, it is constituted through the normative practices embedded in immersion: how researchers position themselves, whose voices are privileged, how responsibility is negotiated, and what forms of change are enacted as being desirable. To make this visible, this paper develops a three-dimensional spectrum of immersive research in which normativity surfaces: (1) the orientation of the research question, (2) researcher positionality, and (3) normative ambition. It then locates five exemplary immersive research approaches – interventionist research, inside-out research, performativist inquiry, engaged ethnography, and non-extractive research – in this spectrum. The spectrum functions as a heuristic positioning device that makes visible the normative architectures through which immersion is organised, renders some forms of change actionable and others less so, and shapes how accountability is distributed. In doing so, this paper contributes to CAR debates by reframing impact as linked to the politics of immersion and by supporting more reflexive research positioning while retaining methodological plurality.