Breaking the Intergenerational Cycle of Abuse: A Randomized Controlled Prevention Trial in Parents with Serious Mental Illness

Authors:
  • CNCorinne Neukel
    Corinne Neukel
  • KWKatharina Williams
    Katharina Williams
  • AGAnna Georg
    Anna Georg
  • JSJudith von Schönfeld
    Judith von Schönfeld
  • NSNikola Schoofs
    Nikola Schoofs
  • CACatherine Hindi Attar
    Catherine Hindi Attar
  • DBDorota Buczylowska
    Dorota Buczylowska
  • KBKatja Boedeker
    Katja Boedeker
  • TDTheresa Dankowski
    Theresa Dankowski
  • MKMichael Kalab
    Michael Kalab

Abstract
Introduction: Although children of parents with mental illness (MI) are at increased risk of adverse childhood experiences and parental maltreatment, prevention trials targeting parents with MI are scarce. In addition, meta-analyses highlight significant methodological shortcomings in the current research. Trial design: The aim of the study was to investigate real-world efficacy of a 12-h mentalization-based parenting counseling (MB-PC) program compared to a psychoeducation workshop (SCC+) as supplements to standard clinical care. Methods: This large-scale, cluster-randomized, open-label (partially observer-blind), active-controlled bicenter superiority trial was conducted at German psychiatric hospitals. It included 252 patients undergoing psychiatric treatment for various serious MIs. MB-PC subsumed five individual sessions including video feedback, five group sessions that guided parents to better understand and respond to their child’s mental states, and two sessions of social counseling, all provided by an interprofessional hospital team of non-psychotherapists. Results: Patients in the MB-PC arm reported improved parenting practices – measured by the Alabama Parenting Questionnaire (APQ) total score as primary outcome – at post-intervention compared to those from the SSC+ arm (effect size [ES] = 0.43, 95% CI [0.13, 0.73], p = 0.004), but group difference decreased at 3-month follow-up (ES = 0.25, 95% CI [−0.04, 0.53], p = 0.085). All secondary outcomes were in favor of the MB-PC intervention, such as parental stress, child abuse potential, and child emotional well-being. Conclusion: Implementing a mentalization-based parenting program in routine psychiatric hospital care may represent an important step forward in reducing the risk of child maltreatment and neglect among offspring of parents affected by severe mental disorders.

This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit: