The differential cross section for the process p(e,e'p)eta has been measured at Q^2 = 2.4 and 3.6 GeV^2 at center-of-mass energies encompassing the S11(1535) resonance. The latter point is the highest-Q^2 exclusive measurement of this process to date. The resonance width Gamma_R and the helicity transition amplitude A^p_{1/2}(Q^2) are extracted from the data. Comparison with a recent analysis of inclusive (e,e') data yields a lower bound of b_{eta} approximately 0.45 for the S11(1535) to eta branching fraction.