The role of transport exclusion and aerial cable cars in shaping commuting choices in steep cities
Authors:
- Santiago Cardona-UrreaSCSantiago Cardona-Urrea
- Jaime Soza-ParraJSJaime Soza-Parra
- Sebastián RaveauSRSebastián Raveau
- Dick EttemaDick Ettema
Preprint
- 3 March 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
This paper investigates the factors affecting commuting mode choice, with a particular focus on the consideration and choice of aerial cable cars (ACC). It also examines the impact of transport-related social exclusion (TRSE) on mode choice, understood as the limited participation in society due to a lack of transport options. The case study is situated in Manizales, Colombia, a medium-sized city renowned for pioneering ACC as a transit mode and distinguished by its steep topography and residential development in hilly terrain, thereby providing a unique context for examining the impact of ACC on mobility. Data was collected through a questionnaire survey, and responses were analysed using factor analysis and a nested logit model. We performed a Confirmatory Factor Analysis on the TRSE scale, based on a structure of six theoretical domains (physical, fear, time, money, information, and geographical-based exclusion) explored in the survey. Interestingly, females show a lower likelihood of choosing the ACC, while the presence of cars among workers also reduces the likelihood of using the ACC. Furthermore, we found that physical, information, and geographical-based exclusion have the potential to explain mode choice. For instance, a high perception of physical-based exclusion, related to the quality of transport infrastructure, reduces the likelihood of choosing transit modes, particularly buses. Additionally, individuals with a higher perception of information-based exclusion tend to favour modes that require less information to ensure a reliable journey, such as the ACC, motorcycle, or walking. Regarding fear-based exclusion, we found that a high fear perception increases the disutility of time; therefore, individuals prefer a faster arrival at the destination, thereby reducing the probability of incidents. Finally, we simulated the modal share with the inauguration of a new ACC line, resulting in a significant increase in the ACC commuting modal share. Nevertheless, new users initially came from buses, showing a lack of attraction for private vehicle users (cars and motorcycles). This study emphasises the importance of including ACC as a mode choice and identifies specific characteristics that influence its selection. Lastly, it highlights the relevance of perceptions of transport-related social exclusion on commuting mode choice by considering distinct effects for particular modes, enabling specific recommendations to improve city mobility.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Activity participation among disadvantaged communities and the impact of an aerial cable car: The case of TransMiCable, BogotáCities, 2025
- Lycra and guardian angels: Can leisure cycling induce travel behaviour changes?Journal of Transport Geography, 2025
- Sufficient access? Activity participation, perceived accessibility and transport-related social exclusion across spatial contextsTransportation, 2024
- Understanding the differences between car and motorcycle ownership. The case of Bogotá, ColombiaJournal of Transport Geography, 2023
- The impact of a new aerial cable-car project on accessibility and CO2 emissions considering socioeconomic stratum. A case study in ColombiaJournal of Cleaner Production, 2022
- Spatial structure, intra-urban commuting patterns and travel mode choice: Analyses of relationships in the Kumasi Metropolis, GhanaCities, 2020
- Apollo: A flexible, powerful and customisable freeware package for choice model estimation and applicationJournal of Choice Modelling, 2019
- Lifting peripheral fortunes: Upgrading transit improves spatial, income and gender equity in MedellinCities, 2017
- An innovative transit system and its impact on low income users: the case of the Metrocable in MedellínJournal of Transport Geography, 2014
- Modelling the social and psychological impacts of transport disadvantageTransportation, 2010