SOME REMARKS ON SUPPLEMENTATION PRINCIPLES IN THE ABSENCE OF ANTISYMMETRY
Author:
- 20 December 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Review of Symbolic Logic
- Vol. 6 (2) , 343-347
Abstract
In response to the paper by Cotnoir and Bacon published in RSL 2/2012, we would like to add some remarks regarding supplementation principles. It is known that in a classical mereology, the Strong Supplementation Principle (SSP) together with antisymmetry enforces the Weak Supplementation Principle (WSP). Instead, in the nonwellfounded mereology, the failure of extensionality causes the failure of antisymmetry (Cotnoir, 2010), hence the investigated model is also nonantisymmetric. Cotnoir supposes that the failure of antisymmetry implies the failure of (WSP) when (PP1) is applied, however gives no explicit argument, which we would like to supply in this paper. Additionally, when (PP2) is applied, (SSP) implies (WSP), hence the failure of antisymmetry does not necessarily imply the failure of (WSP).Keywords
This publication has 2 references indexed in Scilit:
- NON-WELLFOUNDED MEREOLOGYThe Review of Symbolic Logic, 2011
- ANTI-SYMMETRY AND NON-EXTENSIONAL MEREOLOGYThe Philosophical Quarterly, 2010