Drainage Water Management: A Review of Nutrient Load Reductions and Cost Effectiveness
Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers (ASABE) in Journal of the ASABE
- Vol. 67 (4) , 1077-1092
Abstract
Highlights Reductions of nitrogen due to drainage water management were synthesized from 290 plot-years. Nitrate reduction was 13.3 kg N/ha/yr (46%) based on a mixed effects modeling analysis. Dissolved reactive phosphorus and total phosphorus load reductions were 0.04 kg/ha (34%) and 0.06 kg/ha (36%). Cost of nitrogen reduction was $1 to $11 per kg N removed, with a net benefit if yield increased by 3%. Abstract. Drainage water management (DWM) is the practice of seasonally adjusting the drainage outlet elevation with a control structure and is implemented to decrease nutrient loss in drained agricultural landscapes. In this study, we review the effect of DWM on annual nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) loads compared to free drainage and examine its cost-effectiveness using data from around the world published between 1979 and 2022. Studies included in the review were limited to row-crop agriculture without irrigation, with controlled drainage and free drainage compared during the same year. A total of 290 plot-years for N were compiled and analyzed using a mixed effects linear model to assess differences in flow, load, and concentrations and account for within and among site variability. Few studies examined dissolved reactive P (n=7) or total P (n=3); thus, only DRP results from these studies were statistically evaluated using Kruskal-Wallis tests. Analysis of N data showed that DWM reduced N loss on average by 13.3 kg/ha/yr (95% confidence interval: 9.4-17.3 kg/ha/yr), which corresponds to a 46% load removal efficiency (95% confidence interval: 37.4%-54.5%). Drainage water management decreased annual DRP and TP load compared to free drainage by an average of 0.04 kg/ha/yr (mean=34%; range=-35% to 80%) and 0.06 kg/ha/yr (mean=36%; range=7% to 72%), respectively. Economic analysis showed that the cost of N reduction would range from $1 to $11 per kg N removed assuming no yield benefit, while a 3% yield increase would lead to a likely net economic benefit to the producer. Findings indicate that DWM can be an effective practice for decreasing nutrient loading from drained landscapes, however, losses through unmeasured flow paths such as seepage and surface runoff may lead to overestimating the effectiveness of DWM. Additionally, complex interactions among soil organic matter, soil nutrient levels, and water table depths need to be accounted for to ensure both N and P removal is achieved. Recommendations for monitoring discharge and nutrient loads in future DWM studies are provided to better understand the processes influencing nutrient load reductions and/or increases and further quantify the effectiveness of DWM implementation in drained landscapes. Keywords: Agricultural conservation practices, Controlled drainage, Nitrogen, Phosphorus, Subsurface drainage, Water quality.Keywords
All Related Versions
Funding Information
- USDA (2015-68007-23193)
This publication has 67 references indexed in Scilit:
- Efficiency of mitigation measures targeting nutrient losses from agricultural drainage systems: A reviewAMBIO, 2020
- Nutrient loss from floodplain soil with controlled subsurface drainage under forage productionJournal of Environmental Quality, 2020
- A synthesis and comparative evaluation of factors influencing the effectiveness of drainage water managementAgricultural Water Management, 2016
- Drainage water management effects on tile discharge and water qualityAgricultural Water Management, 2015
- Perirheic mixing and biogeochemical processing in flow‐through and backwater floodplain wetlandsWater Resources Research, 2014
- Hydrogeomorphology Influences Soil Nitrogen and Phosphorus Mineralization in Floodplain WetlandsEcosystems, 2012
- Evaluation of controlled drainage efficiency in LithuaniaIrrigation and Drainage, 2011
- Effects of controlled drainage on N and P losses and N dynamics in a loamy sand with spring cropsAgricultural Water Management, 2007
- Controlled drainage for improved water management in arid regions irrigated agricultureAgricultural Water Management, 2006
- Effects of controlled drainage on nitrate concentrations in subsurface drain dischargeAgricultural Water Management, 1996