Testing the validity of lognormal likelihoods for abundance indices in stock assessment models using the generalized gamma distribution
Open Access
- 1 May 2025
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ICES Journal of Marine Science
- Vol. 82 (5)
Abstract
For stock assessments to be accurate, observation models (likelihoods) must accurately reflect data. Many studies have examined age/length composition likelihoods, but few examined abundance indices, which are typically assumed lognormal. Indices from design-based estimators and model-based standardization are sums of positive quantities, but lognormal distributions arise from products of positive quantities, and so lack theoretical justification. We quantified the severity and extent of non-lognormality of indices by fitting the generalized gamma distribution (GGD) to design-based bootstrap biomass estimates across 19 species from Gulf of Alaska survey data. Non-lognormality extent varied by species and year, with less skew than a lognormal common, particularly for species with few zero catches. Age-structured model estimates of spawning biomass using the GGD versus lognormal likelihoods were generally within 5%, with even smaller uncertainty impacts. Overall, we found ample evidence for non-lognormality, but that assessments were not necessarily sensitive to it, particularly for well-sampled species. Impacts may be larger for models without other data (e.g. surplus production models) or for multimodal indices, and corroboration in additional circumstances is critical. Accurately incorporating abundance trends via the index is crucial for fisheries management, and our practical roadmap will help stock assessment authors to test and improve their models.Keywords
This publication has 61 references indexed in Scilit:
- Unimodal density estimation using Bernstein polynomialsComputational Statistics & Data Analysis, 2014
- Review and evaluation of likelihood functions for composition data in stock-assessment models: Estimating the effective sample sizeFisheries Research, 2011
- Parametric survival analysis and taxonomy of hazard functions for the generalized gamma distributionStatistics in Medicine, 2007
- Integrating the standardization of catch-per-unit-of-effort into stock assessment models: testing a population dynamics model and using multiple data typesFisheries Research, 2004
- Standardizing catch and effort data: a review of recent approachesFisheries Research, 2004
- Beyond ‘lognormal versus gamma’: discrimination among error distributions for generalized linear modelsFisheries Research, 2004
- Critique on the use of the delta distribution for the analysis of trawl survey dataICES Journal of Marine Science, 2000
- Trawl survey based abundance estimation using data sets with unusually large catchesICES Journal of Marine Science, 1999
- An Introduction to the Bootstrap1993
- Quantitative Fisheries Stock Assessment1992