Managerial competence as a necessary but insufficient condition for unit-level performance
- 30 June 2026
- journal article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Organizational Effectiveness: People and Performance
- p. 1-47
Abstract
Purpose: This study examines whether managerial competence proficiency influences unit-level performance and whether this relationship is better understood through sufficiency or necessity causal logics. Design/methodology/approach: We analyzed organization-generated competence appraisal data for 674 branch managers from a large nationwide bank. Using both regression analysis and necessary condition analysis (NCA), we examined whether managerial competencies explain variation in unit-level performance and whether minimum competence levels are required for high performance outcomes. Findings: Regression results indicate that managerial competence alone does not strongly explain variation in unit-level performance. However, NCA results suggest that managerial competence functions as a qualifying condition that enables high performance outcomes. Practical implications: The findings suggest that competence-based HR systems may benefit from treating managerial competence as a foundational capability condition that supports high performance when combined with appropriate organizational and contextual factors. Originality/value: This study provides a relatively rare large-scale empirical examination of whether organization-generated managerial competence appraisal data predict unit-level performance. It also contributes by integrating sufficiency- and necessity-based analytical approaches, demonstrating how different causal logics generate distinct interpretations of the competence–performance relationship.Keywords
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- A mixed-methods study of CEO transformational leadership and firm performanceEuropean Management Journal, 2020
- Measuring the organizational impact of training: The need for greater methodological rigorHuman Resource Development Quarterly, 2019
- Reform of the Work Organization: Performance-Related Pay and Employment System2018
- Managerial Core Competencies as Predictors of Managerial Performance, on Different Levels of ManagementProcedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2013
- Toward more accurate contextualization of the CEO effect on firm performanceStrategic Management Journal, 2013
- Does Manager Turnover Improve Firm Performance? Evidence from Dutch Soccer, 1986–2004De Economist, 2011
- The Dilemma of Performance Appraisal2009
- Removing performance appraisal and merit pay in the name of quality: an empirical study of employees' reactionsJournal of Quality Management, 2000
- How much does performance matter? A meta-analysis of CEO pay studiesJournal of Management, 2000
- Determinants of firm performance: The relative importance of economic and organizational factorsStrategic Management Journal, 1989