Preferences as fairness judgments: a critical review of normative frameworks of preference elicitation and development of an alternative based on constitutional economics
Authors:
Open Access
- 30 January 2024
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Cost Effectiveness and Resource Allocation
- Vol. 22 (1) , 1-14
Abstract
Preference elicitation is widely used within health economic evaluations to inform coverage decisions. However, coverage decisions involve questions of social justice and it is unclear what role empirical evidence about preferences can play here. This study reviews the prevalent normative frameworks for using population-based preference elicitation and the criticisms they face, and proposes an alternative based on constitutional economics. The frameworks reviewed include a supposedly value-neutral framework of preferences as predictors of choice, preference utilitarian frameworks that aim to maximize preference satisfaction, and substantive consequentialist frameworks that aim to maximize happiness, health, or capabilities. The proposed alternative implements the idea that indices of social value are tools for conflict resolution, rather than tools for maximization. Preference elicitation is used for validating values generated by multi-criteria decision analysis results within representative processes of stakeholder deliberation.Keywords
Funding Information
- Universität Bremen
This publication has 63 references indexed in Scilit:
- Entscheidungsanalytische Modellierung von Kosten pro QALY im Kontext des deutschen SozialrechtsDas Gesundheitswesen, 2009
- PREFERENCE SATISFACTION AND WELFARE ECONOMICSEconomics and Philosophy, 2009
- Ethics frameworks in Canadian health policies: Foundation, scaffolding, or window dressing?Health Policy, 2009
- Welfarism vs. extra-welfarismJournal of Health Economics, 2008
- The NICE Cost-Effectiveness ThresholdPharmacoEconomics, 2008
- In defence of subjective well-beingHealth Economics, Policy and Law, 2008
- Are subjective well-being measures any better than decision utility measures?Health Economics, Policy and Law, 2008
- The policy analysis of ‘values talk’: lessons from Canadian health reformHealth Policy, 2004
- Theoretical issues in cost-effectiveness analysisJournal of Health Economics, 1997
- Altruism and Economic Behavior, I Developments in the Theory of Public and Private RedistributionThe American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 1980