Comparison of Measurement Methods for Volatile Organic Compounds in Ambient Air Using Adsorbent Tubes and Canisters
Authors:
- Sung-Ok BaekSBSung-Ok Baek
- Young-Kyo SeoYSYoung-Kyo Seo
- Gwi-Seok HeoGHGwi-Seok Heo
- Chan-Gon JeonCJChan-Gon Jeon
- Min-Do LeeMLMin-Do Lee
- Jin-Seok HanJHJin-Seok Han
- 30 June 2016
- journal article
- Published by Korean Society for Atmospheric Environment in Journal of Korean Society for Atmospheric Environment
- Vol. 32 (3) , 305-319
Abstract
Comparison of Measurement Methods for Volatile Organic Compounds in Ambient Air Using Adsorbent Tubes and Canisters VOCs;BTEX;Canister;Adsorbent tube;Inter-lab comparison;QC/QA;GC/MSD; This study was carried out to evaluate the performance of two sampling methods, i.e., adsorbent tubes and canisters, for the measurement of ambient volatile organic compounds (VOCs). A total of 24 target VOCs were selected from a list of 48 priority hazardous air pollutants (HAPs) in Korea. The two sampling methods were investigated with a wide range of performance criteria such as repeatability, linearity, and lower detection limits. In addition, mean relative errors (MRE) and mean duplicate precisions (MDP) were estimated by inter-lab comparison studies for duplicate field samples. Precisions for the two methods appeared to be well comparable with the performance criteria recommended by USEPA TO-15 and TO-17 for canister and adsorbent methods, respectively. Correlations and variations between the VOCs concentrations determined by the two methods were generally good in most cases. However, MREs and MDPs for individual VOCs appeared to be widely ranged, depending on each VOC. This implies that the two methods have its own advantages and disadvantages in determining a variety of VOCs in ambient air, and neither of which has absolute superiority. Finally, 9 of 24 VOCs were found to be difficult to determine by either methods due to their unstability in a canister, and lack of appropriate standard materials. Thus, it is suggested that development of measurement methods for such unstable VOCs is an urgent task from a viewpoint of HAPs management.Keywords
This publication has 5 references indexed in Scilit:
- Characterization of Carbonyl Compounds in the Ambient Air of an Industrial City in KoreaSensors, 2011
- A Study on the Performance Optimization of a Continuous Monitoring Method for Hazardous VOCs in the Ambient AtmosphereJournal of Korean Society for Atmospheric Environment, 2009
- An automated monitoring system for VOC ozone precursors in ambient air: development, implementation and data analysisAnalytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry, 2004
- Monitoring VOCs in Air Using Sorbent Tubes Followed by Thermal Desorption-Capillary GC Analysis: Summary of Data and Practical GuidelinesJournal of the Air & Waste Management Association, 1997
- Applicability of canisters for sample storage in the determination of hazardous air pollutantsAtmospheric Environment, 1995