The Illusion of the Web3 Decentralization: Distributing Power or Creating a New Tech-Savvy Elite?
Author:
Preprint
- 4 November 2024
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
This article critically examines how Web3 decentralization policy trends impact global governance, questioning whether they genuinely distribute power or merely foster a new, tech-savvy elite. Based on fieldwork in Silicon Valley since August 2022 and engagement with scholars and practitioners, the article explores the techno-political ethos shaping the global Web3 movement. While Web3 advocates challenge centralized data monopolies and traditional state structures, this analysis critiques the assumption that Web3 democratizes power, suggesting it may reinforce hierarchies rooted in technical expertise and digital access. The article focuses on three post-Westphalian paradigms influenced by Web3: (i) Network States, (ii) Network Sovereignties, and (iii) Algorithmic Nations. While Network States advocate for crypto-libertarian governance, Network Sovereignties and Algorithmic Nations emphasize cooperative governance aimed at empowering minority communities, such as indigenous groups and e-diasporas, through decentralized, data-driven systems. Despite these promises, the article questions whether Web3 can create a more inclusive global order or if influence is increasingly concentrated among a new elite. This article contributes to debates on sovereignty, governance, and citizenship by advocating hybrid policy frameworks that balance global and local dynamics, emphasizing solidarity, digital justice, and international cooperation for equitable Web3 governance.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- The pursuit of ‘good’ Internet policyPolicy & Internet, 2024
- Engineering Territory: Space and Colonies in Silicon ValleyAmerican Political Science Review, 2023
- Digital nationalism as an emergent subfield of nationalism studies. The state of the field and key issuesNational Identities, 2022
- Indigenous Data Sovereignty in the Era of Big Data and Open DataAustralian Journal of Social Issues, 2020
- Blockchain as a confidence machine: The problem of trust & challenges of governanceTechnology in Society, 2020
- Give Me a Database and I Will Raise the Nation-StateSouth Asia: Journal of South Asian Studies, 2019
- Designer nations: Neo-liberal nation branding – Brand EstoniaSocial Identities, 2008
- Neo‐Nomadism: A Theory of Post‐Identitarian Mobility in the Global AgeMobilities, 2006
- Regulatory ConversationsJournal of Law and Society, 2002
- Governing the Commons1990