Raw scores on subjective sleepiness, fatigue, and vigor metrics consistently define resilience and vulnerability to sleep loss
Open Access
- 9 September 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in SLEEP
- Vol. 45 (1)
Abstract
Although trait-like individual differences in subjective responses to sleep restriction (SR) and total sleep deprivation (TSD) exist, reliable characterizations remain elusive. We comprehensively compared multiple methods for defining resilience and vulnerability by subjective metrics. A total of 41 adults participated in a 13-day experiment: 2 baseline, 5 SR, 4 recovery, and one 36 h TSD night. The Karolinska Sleepiness Scale (KSS) and the Profile of Mood States Fatigue (POMS-F) and Vigor (POMS-V) were administered every 2 h. Three approaches (Raw Score [average SR score], Change from Baseline [average SR minus average baseline score], and Variance [intraindividual SR score variance]), and six thresholds (±1 standard deviation, and the highest/lowest scoring 12.5%, 20%, 25%, 33%, and 50%) categorized Resilient/Vulnerable groups. Kendall’s tau-b correlations compared the group categorization’s concordance within and between KSS, POMS-F, and POMS-V scores. Bias-corrected and accelerated bootstrapped t-tests compared group scores. There were significant correlations between all approaches at all thresholds for POMS-F, between Raw Score and Change from Baseline approaches for KSS, and between Raw Score and Variance approaches for POMS-V. All Resilient groups defined by the Raw Score approach had significantly better scores throughout the study, notably including during baseline and recovery, whereas the two other approaches differed by measure, threshold, or day. Between-measure correlations varied in strength by measure, approach, or threshold. Only the Raw Score approach consistently distinguished Resilient/Vulnerable groups at baseline, during sleep loss, and during recovery‒‒we recommend this approach as an effective method for subjective resilience/vulnerability categorization. All approaches created comparable categorizations for fatigue, some were comparable for sleepiness, and none were comparable for vigor. Fatigue and vigor captured resilience/vulnerability similarly to sleepiness but not each other.Keywords
Funding Information
- Department of the Navy, Office of Naval Research (N00014-11-1-0361)
- National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NNX14AN49G, 80NSSC20K0243)
- National Institutes of Health (NIH R01DK117488)
- Clinical and Translational Research Center (UL1TR000003)
This publication has 84 references indexed in Scilit:
- Trait-Like Vulnerability to Total and Partial Sleep LossSLEEP, 2012
- Acute Versus Chronic Partial Sleep Deprivation in Middle-Aged People: Differential Effect on Performance and SleepinessSLEEP, 2012
- Managing neurobehavioral capability when social expediency trumps biological imperatives2012
- DQB1*0602 predicts interindividual differences in physiologic sleep, sleepiness, and fatigueNeurology, 2010
- Lapsing when sleep deprived: Neural activation characteristics of resistant and vulnerable individualsNeuroImage, 2010
- Do ‘Sleepy’ and ‘Tired’ Go Together? Rasch Analysis of the Relationships between Sleepiness, Fatigue and Nonrestorative Sleep Complaints in a Nonclinical Population SampleNeuroepidemiology, 2010
- Neurocognitive Consequences of Sleep DeprivationSeminars in Neurology, 2009
- Relationships between affect, vigilance, and sleepiness following sleep deprivationJournal of Sleep Research, 2008
- Circadian rhythms in cognitive performance: Methodological constraints, protocols, theoretical underpinningsPhysiology & Behavior, 2007
- Intraindividual Variability May Not Always Indicate Vulnerability in Elders' Cognitive Performance.Psychology and Aging, 2005