The Community-Conservation Conundrum: Is Citizen Science the Answer?
Open Access
Abstract
Public participation theory assumes that empowering communities leads to enduring support for new initiatives. The New Zealand Biodiversity Strategy, approved in 2000, embraces this assumption and includes goals for community involvement in resolving threats to native flora and fauna. Over the last 20 years, community-based ecological restoration groups have proliferated, with between 600 and 4000 identified. Many of these groups control invasive mammals, and often include protection of native species and species reintroductions as goals. Such activities involve the groups in “wicked” problems with uncertain biological and social outcomes, plus technical challenges for implementing and measuring results. The solution might be to develop a citizen science approach, although this requires institutional support. We conducted a web-based audit of 50 community groups participating in ecological restoration projects in northern New Zealand. We found great variation in the quality of information provided by the groups, with none identifying strategic milestones and progress towards them. We concluded that, at best, many group members are accidental scientists rather than citizen scientists. Furthermore, the way community efforts are reflected in biodiversity responses is often unclear. The situation may be improved with a new approach to data gathering, training, and analyses.Keywords
This publication has 65 references indexed in Scilit:
- The history of public participation in ecological researchFrontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 2012
- Co-producing conservation and knowledge: Citizen-based sea turtle monitoring in North Carolina, USASocial Studies of Science, 2012
- A Framework for Assessing Collaborative Capacity in Community-Based Public Forest ManagementEnvironmental Management, 2011
- High levels of participation in conservation projects enhance learningConservation Letters, 2010
- Assessing Environmental Stewardship MotivationEnvironment and Behavior, 2010
- Caught between the Cartographic and the Ethnographic Imagination: The Whereabouts of Amateurs, Professionals, and Nature in Knowing BiodiversityEnvironment and Planning D: Society and Space, 2005
- Rethinking Community‐Based ConservationConservation Biology, 2004
- Psychological Benefits of Volunteering for Restoration ProjectsEcological Restoration, 2000
- Ecological restoration volunteers: the benefits of participationUrban Ecosystems, 1998
- A Ladder Of Citizen ParticipationJournal of the American Institute of Planners, 1969