Large food retail chains have huge influence on food systems, yet their commitment to environmental sustainability varies considerably even when they operate within the same regulatory and market context. Our research compares Germany's leading retail chain's sustainability profiles across environmental dimensions, such as greenhouse gas emissions, packaging reduction, and sustainable sourcing. Drawing on sustainability reports, independent rankings, surveys, media analysis, store observations, and expert interviews, we find substantial variation in environmental performance. The analysis highlights retail format and ownership structure as key determinants shaping sustainability strategies. Discounters, particularly Lidl and Aldi Süd, often outperform full-range supermarkets due to centralized procurement, stronger bargaining power over suppliers, and economies of scale in implementing sustainability measures. In contrast, cooperative supermarket chains such as Edeka and Rewe perform better in regional sourcing as they are locally embedded; also, their business model based on variety entails return systems for reusable bottles, whereas discounters only recycle.