Research assessment using a narrow definition of “research quality” is an act of gatekeeping: A comment on Gärtner et al. (2022)
Author:
Open Access
- 17 March 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Linnaeus University in Meta-Psychology
- Vol. 8
Abstract
Gärtner et al. (2022) propose a system for quantitatively scoring the methodological rigour of papers during the hiring and promotion of psychology researchers, with the aim of advantaging researchers who conduct open, reproducible work. However, the quality criteria proposed for assessing methodological rigour are drawn from a narrow post-positivist paradigm of quantitative, confirmatory research conducted from an epistemology of scientific realism. This means that research conducted from a variety of other approaches, including constructivist, qualitative research, becomes structurally disadvantaged under the new system. The implications of this for particular fields, demographics of researcher, and the future of the discipline of psychology are discussed.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- The institutional impact of research challenges and constraints on psychology and other social and behavioral sciencesNew Ideas in Psychology, 2023
- Open science and epistemic pluralism: A tale of many perils and some opportunitiesIndustrial and Organizational Psychology, 2022
- Disentangling paradigm and method can help bring qualitative research to post-positivist psychology and address the generalizability crisisBehavioral and Brain Sciences, 2022
- The Qualitative Transparency Deliberations: Insights and ImplicationsPerspectives on Politics, 2021
- From Clay Feet to New Psychology: Starting the MoveIntegrative Psychological and Behavioral Science, 2020
- From Psychological Science to the Psychological Humanities: Building a General Theory of SubjectivityReview of General Psychology, 2017
- The Future of Qualitative Research in Psychology: Accentuating the PositiveIntegrative Psychological and Behavioral Science, 2015
- Subjectivity in psychological science: From problem to prospect.Psychological Methods, 2012
- Qualitative research and its place in psychological science.Psychological Methods, 2008
- Qualitative Health Research and the IRB: Answering the “So What?” with Qualitative InquiryJournal of Academic Ethics, 2007