Outcome of lumbar fusion with template-guided cortical bone trajectory versus traditional pedicle screw trajectory – a prospective randomized trial
Open Access
- 27 September 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in European Spine Journal
- p. 1-13
Abstract
Purpose: Traditional trajectory (TT) pedicle screw fixation remains the reference standard for lumbar fusion. Cortical bone trajectory (CBT) screw placement has been proposed as a less invasive alternative with potential biomechanical advantages, but the technique is demanding and its clinical value compared with freehand TT remains uncertain. Patient-specific, CT-based three-dimensional guides may improve CBT screw placement accuracy. The purpose of this randomized prospective trial was to compare fluoroscopy-guided freehand TT with patient-specific, template-guided CBT in lumbar fusion. The primary research question was whether template-guided CBT offers advantages in screw placement accuracy, functional outcomes, paraspinal muscle preservation, fusion status, or complications over 24 months. Methods: Patients undergoing elective lumbar fusion for degenerative spinal disorders were prospectively enrolled and randomized to fluoroscopy-guided freehand TT or patient-specific, template-guided CBT screw placement. Clinical outcomes were assessed using the Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) and visual analog scale scores for back and leg pain. Screw position was assessed using postoperative CT scans and fusion status on 1-year CT scans, paraspinal muscle degeneration was evaluated on MRI. Complications and reoperations were recorded throughout follow-up. Results: Sixty-seven patients were randomized to TT ( n = 34) or CBT ( n = 33). Most patients underwent single-level fusion (91% in TT vs. 97% in CBT). Instrumentation time was longer in the CBT group (25 vs. 18 min, p = 0.030), whereas total operative time and estimated blood loss were comparable. CBT was associated with shorter skin incisions in single-level fusions (9.5 vs. 12.0 cm, p = 0.002) and lower radiation exposure (416.0 vs. 734.5 mGy*cm2, p = 0.013). Intraoperative assessment showed fewer perfectly placed screws in the CBT group (90.3% vs. 100%, p < 0.001), and upper endplate perforation occurred more frequently with CBT (5 vs. 0 screws, p = 0.025). No significant between-group differences were observed in ODI, back or leg pain, pedicle fractures, infection, adjacent segment disease, pseudarthrosis or reoperation rates. At 6 months, maximum paraspinal muscle atrophy was lower in the CBT group (Goutallier grade 3 vs. grade 4, p = 0.037), while mean atrophy was comparable. No radiographic screw loosening was observed in either group at 24 months. Conclusion: In this randomized prospective trial, freehand TT and patient-specific, template-guided CBT resulted in comparable clinical outcomes and overall complication rates at 24 months. CBT reduced radiation exposure, skin incision length, and maximum paraspinal muscle atrophy at 6 months, but these potential perioperative advantages must be balanced against longer instrumentation time, higher implant costs, and a higher rate of upper endplate perforation. Patient-specific, template-guided CBT appears feasible but was not clinically superior to freehand TT in this cohort. Comparisons of infrequent secondary outcomes should be interpreted cautiously because of the limited sample size.Keywords
This publication has 64 references indexed in Scilit:
- Robotic-assisted spine surgery: hype or game-changer?Journal of Robotic Surgery, 2025
- Accuracy of cortical bone trajectory screw placement using patient-specific template guide systemNeurosurgical Review, 2019
- Transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion versus instrumented posterolateral fusion In degenerative spondylolisthesis: An attempt to evaluate the superiority of one method over the otherClinical Neurology and Neurosurgery, 2016
- Comparison of multifidus muscle atrophy after posterior lumbar interbody fusion with conventional and cortical bone trajectoryClinical Neurology and Neurosurgery, 2016
- Early clinical results with cortically based pedicle screw trajectory for fusion of the degenerative lumbar spineJournal of Clinical Neuroscience, 2015
- Junctional spinal disorders in operated adult spinal deformities: present understanding and future perspectivesEuropean Spine Journal, 2013
- Fatty degeneration of multifidus muscle in patients with chronic low back pain and in asymptomatic volunteers: quantification with chemical shift magnetic resonance imagingSkeletal Radiology, 2012
- Cortical bone trajectory for lumbar pedicle screwsThe Spine Journal, 2009
- Use of navigation-assisted fluoroscopy to decrease radiation exposure during minimally invasive spine surgeryThe Spine Journal, 2008
- Transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion: a safe technique with satisfactory three to five year resultsEuropean Spine Journal, 2005