Network Neutrality as Governance Seam

Authors:

Abstract
For the last two decades, commenters have focused on the complex political economy of net neutrality regulations and the swinging pendulum between Republican administrations inclined against imposing regulations and Democratic administrations inclined toward doing so. These debates have obscured the important core of net neutrality: the unique governance seam that the Internet’s protocols create between providers of network infrastructure and the applications that ride atop the Internet. This structural separation is a unique function of deliberate decisions made in the design of the Internet’s architecture, reinforced by social norms, economics, and ultimately by law. While policy conversations have shifted to focus on the power and intermediating function of large social media, search, and other platforms that operate on the application side of the seam, the Internet service providers (“ISPs”) that operate on the network side of the seam quietly remain an essential (path dependent) infrastructure for those platforms. This essay explores the nature of the seam and the core ongoing governance role it plays in Internet-enabled ecosystems. Network neutrality leverages friction-in-design of the Internet’s layered architecture to constrain the ability of network providers to exercise control over user activities, otherwise enabled by their privileged view of traffic flowing across the network. Understanding network neutrality as a governance seam not only adds clarity to the ongoing debates about network neutrality by revisiting and affirming its reinforcing purpose, but also reveals how friction-in-design of many other layered architectures and infrastructural systems can enable good governance and serve social goals.