Can Pahl and Beitz’ systematic approach be a predictive model of designing?
Open Access
- 4 December 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Design Science
- Vol. 3
Abstract
Pahl and Beitz’ ‘Systematic Approach’ is generally seen as a prescriptive model of designing based on observations of professional design practice. In this paper, we examine whether this model can be used as a predictive model. This is done by testing its predictive capacity for the design behaviour of students that are formally taught design and design methods. The behavioural observations used in this study are based on protocols of 15 design sessions involving mechanical engineering students after their first year of design education and 31 design sessions of the students using various concept generation methods. The design protocols and the Systematic Approach are coded uniformly using the Function–Behaviour–Structure (FBS) design issue schema. Cumulative occurrence analysis is used to derive qualitative and quantitative measures as a basis for comparison between the Systematic Approach’s prediction and the students’ design behaviour. The results indicate that the Systematic Approach can predict some but not all of students’ design issue behaviour.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Design cognition differences when using unstructured, partially structured, and structured concept generation creativity techniquesInternational Journal of Design Creativity and Innovation, 2013
- Improving product development process design: a method for managing information flows, risks, and iterationsJournal of Engineering Design, 2011
- Engineering Design Thinking, Teaching, and LearningJournal of Engineering Education, 2005
- The situated function–behaviour–structure frameworkDesign Studies, 2004
- Design Cognition2001
- Why Does Industry Ignore Design Science?Journal of Engineering Design, 1999
- Design Modeling-A Design Science Approach (and Why Does Industry Not Use It?)Journal of Engineering Design, 1998
- An approach to the analysis of design protocolsDesign Studies, 1998
- A review of research in mechanical engineering design. Part I: Descriptive, prescriptive, and computer-based models of design processesResearch in Engineering Design, 1989
- A model of the mechanical design process based on empirical dataArtificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing, 1988