Comparing environmental footprints of haemodialysis and online haemodiafiltration in Italy
Authors:
- James LarkinJLJames Larkin
- Giulia LigabueGLGiulia Ligabue
- Niccolo MorisiNMNiccolo Morisi
- Gaetano AlfanoGaetano Alfano
- Rodrigo Martínez-CadenasRMRodrigo Martínez-Cadenas
- Abass FehintolaAFAbass Fehintola
- Ingeborg SteinbachISIngeborg Steinbach
- Aycan YasarAYAycan Yasar
- Marta Arias-GuillénMAMarta Arias-Guillén
- Francesc Maduell CanalsFrancesc Maduell Canals
- Karin G. F. GerritsenKarin G. F. Gerritsen
- Francis MortimerFMFrancis Mortimer
Open Access
- 3 February 2026
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in International Urology and Nephrology
- Vol. 58 (8) , 3305-3315
Abstract
Background: Haemodialysis (HD) and online haemodiafiltration (OLHDF) are the main in-centre treatments for kidney failure. Both rely on high water and energy use and produce substantial greenhouse gas emissions. OLHDF provides superior solute clearance and improved survival compared with high-flux HD, but its environmental burden remains less defined. Clarifying these differences supports evidence-based and sustainable treatment decisions. Methods: A process-based life cycle assessment (LCA) was performed at the Nephrology, Dialysis and Kidney Transplant Unit, AOU Policlinico di Modena, Italy, in 2024, following ISO 14040 and 14,044 standards. The functional unit was one patient year of treatment, equal to 156 sessions. System boundaries included procurement, water treatment, session operations, travel and waste management. Modelling used OpenLCA with Ecoinvent 3.11 and the Italian electricity grid factor of 0.25 kg CO2 per kWh. Scenarios assessed HD-only, OLHDF-only and the real-world Modena treatment mix. Sensitivity analysis varied the share of OLHDF, session frequency, grid intensity and reverse-osmosis (RO) recovery rate and included a reduced-flow OLHDF prescription. Results: The annual footprint was 4469 kg CO2-eq, 60,290 MJ and 1364 m3 world-eq deprived water per patient year. HD generated 4427 kg CO2-eq and OLHDF 4548 kg CO2-eq, reflecting slightly higher electricity and water consumption and greater plastic use in OLHDF. Travel contributed 71% of total emissions and procurement 21%. Sensitivity analysis showed changes in RO efficiency and electricity mix had stronger effects than treatment type. Conclusions: HD and OLHDF have comparable environmental profiles. Clinical outcomes should drive modality choice, while sustainability gains depend on improving transport, water recovery, energy management and renewable integration.Keywords
All Related Versions
Funding Information
- Horizon 2020 Framework Programme
- University of Dublin, Trinity College
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- A life cycle assessment of peritoneal dialysis procurement in Italy: environmental burden and opportunities for improvementJournal Of Nephrology, 2025
- A health economic evaluation of the multinational, randomized controlled CONVINCE trial: cost-utility of high-dose online hemodiafiltration compared to high-flux hemodialysisKidney International, 2025
- Improving the sustainability and quality of kidney health care through life cycle assessments, quality improvement, education and technical innovations: the KitNewCare approachJournal Of Nephrology, 2024
- How many carbon emissions are saved by doing one less MRI?The Lancet Planetary Health, 2024
- Updating the Data: The Resource Consumption of Modern-Day Hemodialysis SystemsKidney International Reports, 2024
- Effect of Hemodiafiltration or Hemodialysis on Mortality in Kidney FailureNew England Journal of Medicine, 2023
- Green nephrologyNature Reviews Nephrology, 2020
- Global, regional, and national burden of chronic kidney disease, 1990–2017: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2017The Lancet, 2020
- A single number for advocacy and communication—worldwide more than 850 million individuals have kidney diseasesKidney International, 2019
- The ecoinvent database version 3 (part I): overview and methodologyThe International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment, 2016