Identification of Dysfunctional Cooperative Learning Teams Based on Students' Academic Achievement
- 2 January 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Engineering Education
- Vol. 99 (1) , 45-54
Abstract
BackgroundConsiderable evidence exists to suggest that students who study cooperatively reap significant benefits in terms of their learning performance. However, sooner or later, most cooperative learning teams have to deal with one or more members whose actions disturb the team. Unless these problems are quickly resolved, the cooperative learning team gradually becomes dysfunctional and the benefits of cooperative learning are diminished.Purpose (Hypothesis)A method is proposed for identifying dysfunctional cooperative learning teams by comparing the academic achievement of students in a cooperative learning condition with that of students in an individual learning condition.Design/MethodA series of experiments were performed in which 42 sophomore mechanical engineering students were randomly assigned to the two learning conditions and were formed into mixed‐ability groups comprising three team members. The academic performance of the students in the two learning conditions was then systematically compared in terms of their respective test scores.ResultsDysfunctional teams were identified using a new quality index defined as the mean test score of the team divided by the standard deviation of the team members' test scores. The probability of a Type I error was quantified using a control chart. The identification results were verified by analyzing the students' off‐task behavior frequency and attitudes toward cooperative learning, respectively.ConclusionsThe experimental results confirm that the proposed quality index is a potential indicator of dysfunctional cooperative learning teams.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- A review of the one-minute paperActive Learning in Higher Education, 2005
- Effects of Small-Group Learning on Undergraduates in Science, Mathematics, Engineering, and Technology: A Meta-AnalysisReview of Educational Research, 1999
- Cooperative Learning Returns To College What Evidence Is There That It Works?Change: The Magazine of Higher Learning, 1998
- Navigating the Bumpy Road to Student-Centered InstructionCollege Teaching, 1996
- The Effect of Positive Goal and Resource Interdependence on Individual PerformanceThe Journal of Social Psychology, 1996
- Individual versus Group Feedback in Cooperative GroupsThe Journal of Social Psychology, 1994
- Effects of Cooperative and Individualistic Learning on Prospective Elementary Teachers' Music Achievement and AttitudesThe Journal of Social Psychology, 1993
- The Impact of Positive Goal and Resource Interdependence on Achievement, Interaction, and AttitudesThe Journal of General Psychology, 1991
- Oral Interaction in Cooperative Learning Groups: Speaking, Listening, and the Nature of Statements Made by High-, Medium-, and Low-Achieving StudentsThe Journal of Psychology, 1985
- Social Interdependence and Classroom ClimateThe Journal of Psychology, 1983