Accountability and Liability in AI-Related Financial Regulatory Sandboxes: A Comparative Legal Analysis
Author:
Open Access
Abstract
Regulatory sandboxes have evolved from specialised FinTech tools into broader mechanisms of regulatory experimentation. As artificial intelligence (AI) applications become embedded in credit decisioning, payment-fraud detection, identity verification, crypto-asset compliance, customer-facing advice and supervisory analytics, sandbox design increasingly affects how legal and institutional responsibility is allocated among regulators, participating firms, technology vendors and users. This article provides a comparative doctrinal and institutional analysis of accountability and liability in AI-related financial regulatory sandboxes. It clarifies the relevant AI modalities, distinguishes accountability (answerability and enforceability during sandbox participation) from liability (contractual, tort/product and regulatory/public law responsibility after harm), and maps framework-level safeguards across the European Union, the United Kingdom, Singapore, Norway and Hungary. The analysis does not seek to measure sandbox effectiveness empirically. Instead, it examines how publicly available legal and regulatory materials structure the allocation of duties before, during and after sandbox testing. The article shows that sandboxes generally do not operate as liability shields. Their legal significance lies in reallocating ex ante accountability duties—documentation, disclosure, monitoring, human oversight and exit planning—while preserving baseline liability rules. An Accountability and Liability Protocol is proposed to clarify roles, protect baseline consumer rights, support evidentiary traceability and connect sandbox learning to enforceable post-sandbox obligations.Keywords
This publication has 48 references indexed in Scilit:
- What to Expect from the Upcoming EU AI Act Sandboxes: Panel ReportDigital Society, 2025
- The EU Regulatory approach(es) to AI liability, and its Application to the financial services marketComputer Law & Security Review, 2024
- The European Commission's approach to extra-contractual liability and AI – An evaluation of the AI liability directive and the revised product liability directiveComputer Law & Security Review, 2023
- The European AI liability directives – Critique of a half-hearted approach and lessons for the futureComputer Law & Security Review, 2023
- The law and economics of AI liabilityComputer Law & Security Review, 2023
- True uncertainty and ethical AI: regulatory sandboxes as a policy tool for moral imaginationAI and Ethics, 2022
- Regulatory Lag, Regulatory Friction and Regulatory Transition as FinTech Disenablers: Calibrating an EU Response to the Regulatory Sandbox PhenomenonEuropean Business Organization Law Review, 2021
- The ethics of algorithms: key problems and solutionsAI & SOCIETY, 2021
- Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI): Concepts, taxonomies, opportunities and challenges toward responsible AIInformation Fusion, 2020
- The emergence of the global fintech market: economic and technological determinantsSmall Business Economics, 2018