Detecting and Preventing Fraudulent Participation in Qualitative Research: Content Analysis of Two Multisite Studies
Authors:
- Destiny HardenDHDestiny Harden
- Nicolette RodriguezNRNicolette Rodriguez
- Kristi RoybalKRKristi Roybal
- Tara CoffinTCTara Coffin
- Gina JohnsonGJGina Johnson
- Kelley Le BeauxKBKelley Le Beaux
- Maria ConnollyMCMaria Connolly
- Jennifer RountreeJRJennifer Rountree
- Chinedu UkaegbuCUChinedu Ukaegbu
- Anna C RevetteARAnna C Revette
- Brett Nava-CoulterBNBrett Nava-Coulter
- Alyson CarusoACAlyson Caruso
Open Access
- 3 July 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in Journal of Medical Internet Research
- Vol. 28, e87037
Abstract
Background: The use of web-based approaches to identify, recruit, enroll, survey, and interview health-related research participants has increased over time, with rapid acceleration since the COVID-19 pandemic. These approaches can make research more accessible to a broader population, but also increase the risk of fraudulent or imposter participants infiltrating research studies. While this threat has been discussed extensively in quantitative survey research, less has been reported in qualitative and mixed methods studies. Objective: This study aims to identify recurring patterns of fraudulent study participation and to offer strategies for identification, remediation, and reporting. Methods: Encounters with fraudulent or imposter individuals during recruitment, enrollment, survey distribution, data collection, and focus group sessions in 2 multisite qualitative and mixed methods research studies are presented. Content from both studies was analyzed to identify common themes and develop strategies for prevention and remediation. Results: Investigators across 2 multisite studies observed several indicators of suspected fraudulent activity, including large response volumes over a short period, highly repetitive email addresses, higher-than-expected proportions of phone numbers with area codes outside the study area, and unusual email/phone responses using atypical language and phrasing. Several imposter or fraudulent individuals disrupted online focus group sessions. To mitigate these issues, both studies implemented remediation strategies, including enhanced screening procedures at baseline, cross-checking of survey responses, and additional identity verification methods prior to participation. Studies took various actions to address these experiences, including notifying the institutional review board, recruitment platforms, and funders. Conclusions: This multisite study identified multiple ways that imposter or fraudulent participants can pose a significant and evolving threat to the integrity of qualitative and mixed methods. These types of fraudulent actors can distort data and undermine research credibility. Lessons learned highlight the importance of real-time recruitment and enrollment analysis and the need for transparent reporting. Addressing this issue will require a comprehensive approach to prevent and address fraudulent study participation that includes collaboration with multiple stakeholders and the broader research community to effectively address this issue.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Preventing fraudulent research participation: Methodological strategies and ethical impactsJournal of Genetic Counseling, 2025
- A Mixed-Methods Approach to Assessing Barriers and Facilitators to Cancer Genetics Care in Black and Latino/a Individuals Impacted by Pancreatic Cancer: The Racial/ethnic Equity in GENetic Education, Risk Assessment, and TEsting (REGENERATE) StudyDigestive Diseases and Sciences, 2025
- Community Collaboration to Advance Racial/Ethnic Equity in Colorectal Cancer Screening: Protocol for a Multilevel Intervention to Improve Screening and Follow-up in Community Health CentersContemporary Clinical Trials, 2024
- Bots are the new fraud: A post-hoc exploration of statistical methods to identify bot-generated responses in a corrupt data setPersonality and Individual Differences, 2023
- Ensuring survey research data integrity in the era of internet botsQuality & Quantity, 2021
- Bots and nots: safeguarding online survey research with underrepresented and diverse populationsPsychology & Sexuality, 2021
- Extrapulmonary manifestations of COVID-19Nature Medicine, 2020
- The REDCap consortium: Building an international community of software platform partnersJournal of Biomedical Informatics, 2019
- Increasing Response Rate in Web-Based/Internet Surveys2012
- Research electronic data capture (REDCap)—A metadata-driven methodology and workflow process for providing translational research informatics supportJournal of Biomedical Informatics, 2009