Breast tomosynthesis and digital mammography: a comparison of diagnostic accuracy
Authors:
- 1 November 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in British Journal of Radiology
- Vol. 85 (1019) , e1074-e1082
Abstract
Objective: Our aim was to compare the ability of radiologists to detect breast cancers using one-view breast tomosynthesis (BT) and two-view digital mammography (DM) in an enriched population of diseased patients and benign and/or healthy patients. Methods: All participants gave informed consent. The BT and DM examinations were performed with about the same average glandular dose to the breast. The study population comprised patients with subtle signs of malignancy seen on DM and/or ultrasonography. Ground truth was established by pathology, needle biopsy and/or by 1-year follow-up by mammography, which retrospectively resulted in 89 diseased breasts (1 breast per patient) with 95 malignant lesions and 96 healthy or benign breasts. Two experienced radiologists, who were not participants in the study, determined the locations of the malignant lesions. Five radiologists, experienced in mammography, interpreted the cases independently in a free-response study. The data were analysed by the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) and jackknife alternative free-response ROC (JAFROC) methods, regarding both readers and cases as random effects. Results: The diagnostic accuracy of BT was significantly better than that of DM (JAFROC: p=0.0031, ROC: p=0.0415). The average sensitivity of BT was higher than that of DM (∼90% vs ∼79%; 95% confidence interval of difference: 0.036, 0.108) while the average false-positive fraction was not significantly different (95% confidence interval of difference: −0.117, 0.010). Conclusion: The diagnostic accuracy of BT was superior to DM in an enriched population.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- New Developments in Observer Performance Methodology in Medical ImagingSeminars in Nuclear Medicine, 2011
- What is the lifetime risk of developing cancer?: the effect of adjusting for multiple primariesBritish Journal of Cancer, 2011
- The diagnostic accuracy of dual-view digital mammography, single-view breast tomosynthesis and a dual-view combination of breast tomosynthesis and digital mammography in a free-response observer performance studyRadiation Protection Dosimetry, 2010
- VIEWDEX: an efficient and easy-to-use software for observer performance studiesRadiation Protection Dosimetry, 2010
- Breast tomosynthesis in clinical practice: initial resultsEuropean Radiology, 2009
- Dedicated Breast CT: Initial Clinical ExperienceRadiology, 2008
- Diagnostic Accuracy of Digital versus Film Mammography: Exploratory Analysis of Selected Population Subgroups in DMISTRadiology, 2008
- A search model and figure of merit for observer data acquired according to the free-response paradigmPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2006
- Recent advances in observer performance methodology: jackknife free-response ROC (JAFROC)Radiation Protection Dosimetry, 2005
- “Proper” Binormal ROC Curves: Theory and Maximum-Likelihood EstimationJournal of Mathematical Psychology, 1999