Deception, Discrimination, and Fear of Reprisal: Lessons in Ethics from Third-Year Medical Students
Authors:
- Catherine V. CaldicottCCCatherine V. Caldicott
- Kathy Faber-LangendoenKFKathy Faber-Langendoen
- 1 September 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Academic Medicine
- Vol. 80 (9) , 866-873
Abstract
To systematically examine ethical conflicts reported by all State University of New York Upstate Medical University third-year students, compare them with conflicts reported in the literature, and identify content areas that compel new or renewed emphasis in national educational objectives, standard curricula, and texts. From 1999 to 2002, all third-year students submitted papers for a required bioethics course. These papers depicted ethical issues arising during clinical clerkships. The authors devised a checklist of ethical issues; after analyzing the students’ papers, the authors applied the checklist to the papers to create a taxonomy. Three hundred twenty-seven students submitted 688 cases involving 40 ethical issues. The most common issues were deliberate lies or deceptions (n = 68), patients’ right to refuse recommended treatment (n = 48), and insistence on futile treatment (n = 46). Students perceived overt and subtle discrimination toward patients, reflected in substandard or excessive treatment. In 81 cases (12%), students expressed reluctance to speak up about moral conflict for fear of reprisal. This fear was expressed in 18 (45%) of the 40 issues—particularly student-specific (36 [52% of 69]) and quality of care (7 [24% of 29])—and most frequently in cases involving surgery (p < .025) and obstetrics–gynecology patients (p < .01). Students discerned ethical dilemmas in both “usual and customary” and seemingly incidental situations. Students who described fear of speaking up perceived a tradeoff between academic survival and patients’ interests. The cases demonstrated that students still lacked the tools to navigate ethical dilemmas effectively. The authors propose that moral courage is within the realm of professional expectations for medical students; its cultivation is an appropriate formal objective for medical education.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Using the American Board of Internal Medicineʼs “Elements of Professionalism” for Undergraduate Ethics EducationAcademic Medicine, 2002
- Negotiating Cross-Cultural Issues at the End of LifeJAMA, 2001
- Medical Studentsʼ Cases as an Empirical Basis for Teaching Clinical EthicsAcademic Medicine, 2000
- Review of ethics curricula in undergraduate medical educationMedical Education, 2000
- Learning Objectives for Medical Student Education— Guidelines for Medical Schools: Report I of the Medical School Objectives ProjectJournal of the Association of American Medical Colleges, 1999
- Teaching medical ethics and law within medical education: a model for the UK core curriculum.Journal of Medical Ethics, 1998
- Medical studentsʼ perceptions of unethical conduct at one medical schoolAcademic Medicine, 1998
- A data-generated basis for medical ethics educationAcademic Medicine, 1995
- Ethics in a short white coatAcademic Medicine, 1993
- The importance of listening to medical students' experiences when teaching them medical ethics.Journal of Medical Ethics, 1989