Does capital depend on unpaid reproductive labour? Revisiting John Harrison’s political economy of housework
- 1 November 2026
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Capital & Class
Abstract
This comment revisits John Harrison’s 1973 analysis of housework in light of Gao and Bai’s recent costs-of-consumption framework. Its central claim is that Harrison should not be read simply as a representative of the “benefit position.” His model is better understood as a counterfactual replacement-cost analysis: taking the productivity of household provision relative to its market substitutes as a key variable, it asks when a given reproductive function is more advantageous to capital as unpaid household labour, and when its commodified substitute becomes preferable. This shifts the debate from the general claim that capitalism depends on unpaid reproductive labour to a more precise comparative question about the social forms of reproduction. Capitalism may still depend on some non-commodified background, but any systemic limit to commodification would require a separate explanation.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Marx’s ‘costs of consumption’: A new framework for analysing the economic character of ‘reproductive labour’Capital & Class, 2026
- The Ecological Implication of Marx’s Labor Theory of ValueSociety, 2024
- Domestic-Labour Debate2023
- Invisible Exploitation: How Capital Extracts Value Beyond Wage LaborMonthly Review, 2018
- Crisis of Care? On the Social-Reproductive Contradictions of Contemporary Capitalism2017
- Can society be commodities all the way down? Post-Polanyian reflections on capitalist crisisEconomy and Society, 2014
- When a Commodity Is Not Exactly a CommodityScience, 2008
- Exploitation comes home: a critique of the Marxian theory of family labourCambridge Journal of Economics, 1982
- From reproduction to productionEconomy and Society, 1972
- The Political Economy of Women's LiberationMonthly Review, 1969