Abstract
As independent experts within the UN system, special procedures play a unique role in calling attention to emerging and chronic human rights problems and calling on states to improve their performance in accordance with international law. Yet there is no empirical study documenting what kind of impact they have at the national level. Based on an exhaustive review of nearly 9000 communications by 17 thematic mandates to 174 states, as well as field research and interviews with over 200 experts, our research team concluded that this mechanism plays a direct, positive but uneven role in influencing government behaviour. Lack of state cooperation with special procedures represents the chief obstacle to their work. They are also hobbled by a host of other challenges, including inadequate resources and training, insufficient understanding of the local context for their work, and the lack of a systematic process for following up their recommendations. Despite these obstacles, the special procedures mechanism represents one of the most effective tools of the international human rights system, but needs further strengthening and support.