Organizational listening to external stakeholders is not receiving the attention that it deserves. Through a mixed-method study that included interviews with communication managers and a national survey with US employees, we discovered that although organizations attempt to listen to external stakeholders, their efforts are often ineffective, especially in the areas of collecting critiques, dissent, and bad news. This finding is problematic because effective listening is a critical component of effective issues management. The participants also shared specific examples of effective listening and the financial and reputational consequences associated with not seeking input from external stakeholders. Based on these findings, we provide specific recommendations for the incorporation of listening in organizations to improve their issues management practice and relationships with external stakeholders.