In the Halfway House of Ill Repute: Gender Verification under a Different Name, Still No Contribution to Fair Play
- 23 December 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Sport, Ethics and Philosophy
- Vol. 7 (4) , 450-466
Abstract
The aftermath of Caster Semenya’s resounding victory in the women’s 800 m at the 2009 Athletics World Championships in Berlin highlighted the ethical and scientific flaws of gender verification in women’s athletics. It has led the governing international body of professional athletics, the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF), to adopt new rules regarding athletes with differences of sexual developments (DSDs) in women’s competitions in 2011 (Regulations on Hyperandrogenism). The International Olympic Committee followed suit and adopted a similar set of rules in 2012. Locating the practice of gender verification in a history of sexist stereotyping of women athletes (in Section 1), I argue (in Section 2), following other critics, that the IAAF’s new rules suffer from the same ethical flaws as their predecessors; and specifically that they still invite and rely on qualitative measuring of an athlete’s femininity and masculinity. In the central section of this paper (Section 3), I relate the practice of gender verification to the vexing question of what constitutes an unfair advantage in sports. I suggest, first, that athletes with a DSD should be at liberty to exploit competitive advantages their conditions might confer on them, just as most athletes in most sports are at liberty to exploit their congenital traits (the only irrelevant difference being that DSDs are construed as gendered advantages). In a second step, I argue that gender segregation in sports and gender verification practices cannot both be defended by an appeal to fairness. If we want to preserve gender segregation, then we ought to give up gender verification; and if we are not prepared to give up regulation of gendered congenital advantages, then we ought to give up gender segregation in favor of a classification system that tracks genetic predisposition rather than gender.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Harrison Bergeron olympics.The American Journal of Bioethics, 2013
- Are the New Policies on Hyperandrogenism in Elite Female Athletes Really Out of Bounds? Response to “Out of Bounds? A Critique of the New Policies on Hyperandrogenism in Elite Female Athletes”The American Journal of Bioethics, 2013
- Policing the Boundaries of Sex: A Critical Examination of Gender Verification and the Caster Semenya ControversyThe Journal of Sex Research, 2013
- Testing Sex, Attributing Gender: What Caster Semenya Means to Women’s SportsJournal of Intercollegiate Sport, 2011
- The Illusory “Level Playing Field”2010
- Sex Typing for SportHastings Center Report, 2010
- Transsexuals in Sport–Fairness and Freedom, Regulation and LawSport, Ethics and Philosophy, 2008
- Who's afraid of Stella Walsh? On gender, ‘gene cheaters’, and the promises of cyborg athletesSport, Ethics and Philosophy, 2007
- Essay: Gender verification of female athletesThe Lancet, 2005
- The Use and Misuse of Sex Chromatin Screening for `Gender Identification' of Female AthletesJAMA, 1986