Public Health Decision Making during Covid-19 — Fulfilling the CDC Pledge to the American People

Authors:

Abstract
In May 2020, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) released considerations for the opening of elementary and high schools in the fall in light of the Covid-19 pandemic. The agency also developed a decision tool to guide school systems in deciding when schools should be opened and a 9-page checklist for school administrators with policies and procedures, facilities and supplies, and education and training needed for safe reopening of schools. The day after a July 7 meeting at the White House to discuss school reopening with school system administrators, teachers, and students, President Donald Trump expressed concern about the practicality of the guidelines and the expenses associated with following them; later that day, Vice President Mike Pence announced that the CDC would be revising the guidelines. The next day, the CDC director clarified that the guidelines would not be revised, but that additional reference documents would be provided to aid communities as they worked to implement the guidelines. On July 23, the CDC released additional documents emphasizing the critical role of schools and the importance of opening them for in-person instruction. This interchange among federal leaders raises concern that during the response to the most critical public health emergency of our lifetimes, guidelines regarding the safety of schoolchildren in the United States could be based not on the best scientific data available, but on political considerations.