Moving beyond panaceas in fisheries governance
Authors:
- 23 August 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 115 (37) , 9065-9073
Abstract
In fisheries management—as in environmental governance more generally—regulatory arrangements that are thought to be helpful in some contexts frequently become panaceas or, in other words, simple formulaic policy prescriptions believed to solve a given problem in a wide range of contexts, regardless of their actual consequences. When this happens, management is likely to fail, and negative side effects are common. We focus on the case of individual transferable quotas to explore the panacea mindset, a set of factors that promote the spread and persistence of panaceas. These include conceptual narratives that make easy answers like panaceas seem plausible, power disconnects that create vested interests in panaceas, and heuristics and biases that prevent people from accurately assessing panaceas. Analysts have suggested many approaches to avoiding panaceas, but most fail to conquer the underlying panacea mindset. Here, we suggest the codevelopment of an institutional diagnostics toolkit to distill the vast amount of information on fisheries governance into an easily accessible, open, on-line database of checklists, case studies, and related resources. Toolkits like this could be used in many governance settings to challenge users’ understandings of a policy’s impacts and help them develop solutions better tailored to their particular context. They would not replace the more comprehensive approaches found in the literature but would rather be an intermediate step away from the problem of panaceas.Keywords
This publication has 144 references indexed in Scilit:
- The triple bottom line: Meeting ecological, economic and social goals with individual transferable quotasJournal of Environmental Economics and Management, 2012
- Constant proportion harvest policies: Dynamic implications in the Pacific halibut and Atlantic cod fisheriesMathematical Biosciences, 2011
- How actions create – not just reveal – preferencesTrends in Cognitive Sciences, 2008
- Panaceas, uncertainty, and the robust control framework in sustainability scienceProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2007
- Beyond panaceas in water institutionsProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2007
- A diagnostic approach for going beyond panaceasProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2007
- System evaluation of sustainability in the Norwegian cod-fisheriesMarine Policy, 2007
- Management of summer-spawning herring off IcelandICES Journal of Marine Science, 1999
- Social theory and fisheries co-managementMarine Policy, 1998
- Use of the availability heuristic in probability estimates of future events: The effects of imagining outcomes versus imagining reasonsOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1987