When Do Structural Holes Yield Breakthrough Innovation? An Inverted U-Shape Bounded by Collaboration-Layer Centralities
Open Access
Abstract
Breakthrough innovation—central to industrial competitiveness and the ongoing clean-energy transition—remains persistently constrained by information homogenization and weak cross-domain integration in single-layer innovation networks. Technology Innovation Composite Networks (TICNs) have therefore been advocated as dual-layer platforms coupling knowledge and collaboration networks, yet the cross-layer mechanism through which they generate breakthrough outputs has not been specified. This paper specifies and tests how knowledge-layer structural holes open access to heterogeneous information that must cross into the collaboration layer to be recombined into breakthroughs. Two distinct boundaries shape the outcome. Inventors’ finite cognitive processing capacity makes integration returns decay along an inverted U-shape; separately, excessive degree and closeness centrality drive the collaboration layer into homogenization and localization, narrowing the range of structural holes it can productively absorb and shifting the breakthrough peak toward lower structural-hole levels. Together, they delineate an optimal cross-layer integration zone. Using panel data on 10,681 patents, 948 inventors, and 5631 inventor-year observations from new energy (2004–2018), a fixed-effects negative binomial model confirms the inverted U-shape and the steepening, peak-shifting moderations of degree and closeness centrality; a Lind–Mehlum test places the turning point inside the observed data range, and negative binomial (robust SE), Poisson and zero-inflated Poisson specifications—together with a stricter top-1% breakthrough threshold—yield consistent results. The study moves multilayer network research from structural description toward mechanism-level identification and offers actionable network-design guidance.Keywords
This publication has 62 references indexed in Scilit:
- Rise of Generative Artificial Intelligence in ScienceScientometrics, 2025
- Co-creation of metaverse brands equity with the impact of celebrity virtual images and real-life influence: from the perspective of experience-dominant logicElectronic Commerce Research, 2024
- The effect of structural holes on producing novel and disruptive research in physicsScientometrics, 2023
- The effect of strategic synergy between local and neighborhood environmental regulations on green innovation efficiency: The perspective of industrial transferJournal of Cleaner Production, 2022
- New energy utilization in environmental design and realizationEnergy Reports, 2022
- Does technology conglomeration promote innovative outcomes of new energy vehicle enterprises? The moderating effect of divisive faultlinesJournal of Cleaner Production, 2021
- Urban network externalities, agglomeration economies and urban economic growthCities, 2020
- Information and communication technology overload and social networking service fatigue: A stress perspectiveComputers in Human Behavior, 2016
- The double‐edged sword of recombination in breakthrough innovationStrategic Management Journal, 2014
- Citation success over time: theory or empirics?Scientometrics, 2012