Competing philosophies in the classroom: a challenge to Hong Kong teachers
Authors:
- Donna Kam Pun WongDWDonna Kam Pun Wong
- Veronica PearsonVPVeronica Pearson
- Eva Mei Kuen LoELEva Mei Kuen Lo
- 1 July 2004
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Inclusive Education
- Vol. 8 (3) , 261-279
Abstract
The present paper examines the experiences of teachers in teaching children with special needs in mainstream schools and how they see and evaluate the feasibility of the new integration initiatives in Hong Kong. The data are based on individual and focus group interviews with general class teachers, resource class teachers and principals of mainstream schools admitting students with special needs. Teachers reported difficulties and problems in maintaining classroom discipline and ambivalence in meeting the competing demands between students with and without special needs. The structural constraints of implementing a rigidly defined curriculum and being accountable for good academic results regardless of student competence pose formidable obstacles in achieving the goals of integrated education. There is a conflict at the systemic level between the philosophy of academic excellence defined by grades on the one hand and the philosophy of equality and inclusion on the other. Improving parent participation, having an ample supply of funds, the provision of necessary equipment and facilities, the availability of pre‐ and in‐service training to teachers, and additional manpower in counselling are the most urgently needed resources in facilitating teachers to engage in teaching students with special needs alongside others.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- 'I wasn't trained to work with them': mainstream teachers' attitudes to children with speech and language difficultiesInternational Journal of Inclusive Education, 2002
- Collaboration and compromise in creating and sustaining an inclusive schoolInternational Journal of Inclusive Education, 2001
- Inclusion needs a different school cultureInternational Journal of Inclusive Education, 1999
- Inclusive education and school cultureInternational Journal of Inclusive Education, 1999
- 'A Luxury for the First World': A Western perception of Hong Kong Chinese attitudes towards inclusive educationDisability & Society, 1998
- A Perspective on Inclusion from EnglandCambridge Journal of Education, 1996
- Classroom Groups: Inclusion of Students With DisabilitiesThe Journal for Specialists in Group Work, 1995
- The Success of Collaboration Resource Programs for Students with Disabilities in Grades 6 Through 8Remedial and Special Education, 1995
- The Special/General Education Integration Initiative for Students with Specific Learning DisabilitiesJournal of Learning Disabilities, 1994
- Teacher Educator Predictions of Regular Class Teacher Perceptions of MainstreamingTeacher Education and Special Education: The Journal of the Teacher Education Division of the Council for Exceptional Children, 1991