‘Grand challenge’ or ‘not an issue’? The discourses on income inequality of compensation managers and consultants
- 13 November 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The International Journal of Human Resource Management
- Vol. 32 (20) , 4363-4391
Abstract
Within the broader debate on the increase of labor income inequality, social concerns have growingly focused on organizational practices. Among these, market-oriented compensation practices, with their extensive pay dispersion, are deemed crucial ‘inequality-generators’. Based on 49 interviews with Italian compensation managers and consultants, this article explores whether, in their talk, these actors align with (or detach from) inequality-increasing compensation practices, and which discourses they employ to justify their posture. By resorting to the discourses on meritocracy and market, the respondents fully supported dispersed market-based compensation structures, thus endorsing a motivation- (rather than legitimacy-) centered approach informed by a shareholder (rather than a stakeholder) perspective. In countering possible criticisms, they advanced two main discursive responses: ‘transparent communication’, i.e. communication intended to convince critics about the benefits of merit-based and market-based pay dispersion; and ‘populism’, i.e. a term used to discredit those critics that question any type of pay dispersion. Assuming a discursive approach, the paper adds an HRM perspective to the growing debate on the role of organizations in producing and re-producing income inequality, while critically showing that compensation managers and consultants fail as a resource for inequality reduction.Keywords
This publication has 85 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Employment Relationship and Inequality: How and Why Changes in Employment Practices are Reshaping Rewards in OrganizationsAcademy of Management Annals, 2013
- The Price of InequalityNew Perspectives Quarterly, 2013
- Seeking Qualitative Rigor in Inductive ResearchOrganizational Research Methods, 2012
- Green Human Resource Management: A Review and Research Agenda*International Journal of Management Reviews, 2012
- The trouble with HRMHuman Resource Management Journal, 2011
- Organizational Approaches to Inequality: Inertia, Relative Power, and EnvironmentsAnnual Review of Sociology, 2010
- Inequality and Union Membership: The Influence of Relative Earnings and Inequality AttitudesBritish Journal of Industrial Relations, 2010
- Reinventing human resource management: Business partners, internal consultants and the limits to professionalizationHuman Relations, 2008
- Inequality: Causes and ConsequencesAnnual Review of Sociology, 2007
- How Many Interviews Are Enough?Field Methods, 2006