A Planning Tool for Watershed LID-BMP Implementation

Authors:

Abstract
The paper describes the development of a planning tool for comparing different LID-type BMP implementation scenarios in a watershed and selecting the optimal spatial placement strategy for the BMPs. The framework of the planning tool includes the following components: A watershed model, which simulates nonpoint pollutant loads from all parts of the watershed under given wet-weather conditions; A sub-program that performs computations of the water quality impact of the implementation of LID-type BMPs such as bioreention cells in a watershed; An "optimization" tool, which will search for the optimal scenario for BMP placement in the watershed. In the present study, a watershed model developed at the University of Virginia, called WINVAST, was used. WINVAST is a comprehensive, event-based stormwater model, which simulates pollutant loads generated from a given storm event and has interfacing capability with GIS databases. A sub-program to the WINVAST model was developed to simulate certain BMP processes (currently wet detention ponds and grassed swales) in a watershed. The optimization tool used in the present study was the "Scattered Search" methodology. A tributary watershed to the Swift Creek Reservoir near Richmond, Virginia was used as a case study. Several BMP implementation scenarios were tested, namely, on-site or micro-scale such as LID-types, sub-regional and regional placement of BMPs. The results show that the on-site placement scheme would cause a larger reduction of watershed runoff peaks, but the water quality results were mixed. On the other hand, when watershed water quality requirement is higher, the placement of BMPs tends to favor locations closer to the watershed outlet over upstream locations on a cost-effectiveness basis. The results also show that when the maintenance cost was tied with the amount of sediment accumulation in a pond BMP, the overall system cost would be lower.