Poor reliability and reproducibility of 3 different radiographical classification systems for distal ulna fractures
Open Access
- 18 April 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Medical Journals Sweden AB in Acta Orthopaedica
- Vol. 93, 438-443
Abstract
Background and purpose: Classification of fractures can be valuable for research purposes but also in clinical work. Especially with are fractures, such as distal ulna fractures, a treatment algorithm based on a classification can be helpful. We compared 3 different classification systems of distal ulna fractures and investigated their reliability and reproducibility.Patients and methods: patients with 97 fractures of the distal ulna, excluding the ulnar styloid, were included. All fractures were independently classified by 3 observers according to the classification by Biyani, AO/OTA 2007, and AO/OTA 2018. The classification process was repeated after a minimum of 3 weeks. We used Kappa value analysis to determine inter- and intra-rater agreement.Results: The inter-rater agreement of the AO/OTA 2007 classification was judged as fair, ĸ 0.40, whereas the agreement of AO/OTA 2018 and Biyani was moderate at ĸ 0.42 and 0.43 respectively. The intra-rater agreement was judged as moderate for all classifications.Interpretation: The differences between the classifications were small and the overall impression was that neither of them was good enough to be of substantial clinical value. The Biyani classification, being developed specifically for distal ulna fractures, was the easiest and most fitting for the fracture patterns seen in our material, but lacking options for fractures of the distal diaphysis. Standard radiographs were considered insufficient for an accurate classification. A better radiographic method combined with a revised classification might improve accuracy, reliability, and reproducibility.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Role of Cone-Beam Computed Tomography (CBCT) Scan for Detection and Follow-Up of Traumatic Wrist PathologiesThe Journal of Hand Surgery, 2019
- Radius and UlnaJournal of Orthopaedic Trauma, 2018
- Classification systems for distal radius fracturesActa Orthopaedica, 2017
- Similar 1-year subjective outcome after a distal radius fracture during the 10-year-period 2003–2012Acta Orthopaedica, 2017
- Incidence des fractures de l’extrémité distale de l’ulna associées aux fractures de l’extrémité distale du radius (processus styloïde ulnaire). Nos choix thérapeutiquesHand Surgery and Rehabilitation, 2016
- Does the CT improve inter- and intra-observer agreement for the AO, Fernandez and Universal classification systems for distal radius fractures?Injury, 2014
- The Influence of Three-Dimensional Computed Tomography Reconstructions on the Characterization and Treatment of Distal Radial FracturesJournal of Bone and Joint Surgery, 2006
- How reliable are reliability studies of fracture classifications?A systematic review of their methodologiesActa Orthopaedica, 2004
- Fractures of the Distal Radius and UlnaJournal of Hand Surgery (European Volume), 1995
- The Measurement of Observer Agreement for Categorical DataBiometrics, 1977