Qualitative study of pilot payment aimed at increasing general practitioners' antismoking advice to smokers
Authors:
Abstract
Objectives: To elicit general practitioners' and practice nurses' accounts of changes in their clinical practice or practice organisation made to claim a pilot health promotion payment. To describe attitudes towards the piloted and previous health promotion payments. Design: Qualitative, semistructured interview study. Setting: 13 general practices in Leicester. Participants: 18 general practitioners and 13 practice nurses. Results: Health professionals did not report substantially changing their clinical practice to claim the new payments and made only minimal changes in practice organisation. The new health promotion payment did not overcome general practitioners' resistance towards raising the issue of smoking when they felt that doing so could cause confrontation with patients. General practitioners who made the largest number of claims altered the way in which they recorded patients' smoking status rather than raising the topic of smoking more frequently with patients. Participants had strong negative views on the new payment, feeling it would also be viewed negatively by patients. They were, however, more positive about health promotion payments that rewarded “extra” effort — for example, setting up practice based smoking cessation clinics. Conclusions: General practitioners and practice nurses were negative about a new health promotion payment, despite agreeing to pilot it. Health promotion payments do not automatically generate effective health promotion activity, and policymakers should consider careful piloting and evaluation of future changes in health promotion payments.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Capitation, salary, fee-for-service and mixed systems of payment: effects on the behaviour of primary care physiciansCochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2000
- Prevention in practice: results of a 2-year follow-up of routine health promotion interventions in general practiceFamily Practice, 1996
- Qualitative research in health care: I. The scope and validity of methodsJournal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 1996
- Qualitative Research: Qualitative interviews in medical researchBMJ, 1995
- General practitioners and the new contract: promoting better health through financial incentivesHealth Policy, 1993
- Minor surgery by general practitioners under the 1990 contract: effects on hospital workload.BMJ, 1993
- The effect of per-item fees on the behaviour of general practitionersJournal of Health Economics, 1992
- Primary and preschool immunisation in Grampian: progress and the 1990 contract.BMJ, 1992
- Cervical screening in Perth and Kinross since introduction of the new contract.BMJ, 1991
- Thinking Prevention: Concepts and Constructs in General Practice1988