Comedy as cure for tragedy: Act up and the rhetoric of aids
Authors:
- 1 May 1996
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Quarterly Journal of Speech
- Vol. 82 (2) , 157-170
Abstract
The rhetorical strategies of the direct action AIDS organization, ACT UP, are analyzed using Kenneth Burke's concept of the comic frame. Commentators have criticized ACT UP for its rude, angry, irreverent, and indecorous demonstrations. The group's actions reflect the immediate danger of AIDS‐related sickness and death that many ACT UP protesters face; they also reflect the group's reliance on the comic frame as a way of contending with the onus of being named the scapegoats for introducing AIDS to the United States. In contrast to the prevailing tragic frame, comic rhetoric is hopeful and humane because it invites reconciliation and affirms the importance of rationality and community. ACT UP's challenge to the prevailing tragic frame of guilt‐victimage‐redemption‐purification was designed to reposition its members as part of the community and reframe the AIDS crisis in realistic, humane, and pragmatic terms. The study suggests conditions under which other despised and oppressed groups may respond after having been scapegoated by society.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- A dramatistic theory of apocalyptic rhetoricQuarterly Journal of Speech, 1993
- Performing Anger: Emotion in Strategic Responses to AIDSThe Australian Journal of Anthropology, 1993
- From “gay is good” to the scourge of AIDS: The evolution of gay liberation rhetoric, 1977‐1990Communication Studies, 1991
- The Implicated and the Immune: Responses to AIDS in the Arts and Popular Culture1991
- Silence, Death, and the Invisible Enemy: AIDS Activism and Social Movement "Newness"Social Problems, 1989
- The process of politicalpraxis:Efforts of the gay community to transform the social signification of AIDSCommunication Quarterly, 1989
- Limitations on the comic frame: Some witty American women of the nineteenth centuryQuarterly Journal of Speech, 1988
- Making light of James Watt: A Burkean approach to the form and attitude of political cartoonsQuarterly Journal of Speech, 1987
- Gandhi and the comic frame: “Ad bellum purificandum”Quarterly Journal of Speech, 1986
- The rhetoric of confrontationQuarterly Journal of Speech, 1969