A changing climate, receding sea ice, and expanding maritime shipping are elevating the risk of oil spills across the circumpolar northern hemisphere. Arctic cod, an energy-rich keystone forage fish for marine mammals, seabirds, and commercially-important fisheries, are particularly sensitive to crude oil developmental toxicity. Highly buoyant cod embryos interact with dispersed oil droplets in surface slicks, enhancing exposure to cardiotoxic polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and other chemicals in complex petroleum mixtures. However, distinct crude oils from different geological sources are now being transported across the Arctic via newly-accessible shipping routes, and compositional dissimilarity among crudes is complicating oil spill planning and risk assessment. To address uncertainty associated with mixture complexity and the causal chemical agents for developmental injury to fish, we compared the etiology of two different oils from Arctic formations, including Alaska North Slope crude oil (ANSCO) and Kobbe crude oil (KCO) from the Barents Sea off Norway. The two oils have a similar PAH content yet dramatically different proportions of largely uncharacterized polar compounds. Despite this variation in the polar fraction, we show that ANSCO and KCO produce the same patterns of cardiac and craniofacial injury to developing Arctic cod, with indistinguishable dose-response relationships based on tissue PAH measures. Adverse impacts on cardiac function and morphogenesis were evident at the lowest tested exposure concentrations [14 µg/L oil; ∑PAH 0.5 µg/L], indicating a high tissue PAH accumulation due to egg-droplet interaction. Dose-response modeling showed that reduction in heart rate and contractility were most robustly associated with the three-ring PAH sub-fraction. Therefore, future disaster planning for high-latitude food webs should prioritize tricyclic PAHs as predominant threats to vulnerable Arctic cod spawning habitats, irrespective of petroleum source.