Balls and All

Author:
  • DNDaniel Nolan
    Daniel Nolan

Abstract
This chapter describes a view of the nature of physical objects, their mereological connections to each other, and their relation to spacetime. The key primitives of this view are two spatio-temporal ones: ‘is a sub-region of’ and ‘is a (four-dimensional) ball’. With these primitives it is possible to define a four-dimensional Euclidean space, a space where regions are in no sense made up of points. All the other physical primitives of the system can be predicates of regions. This view provides a plausible context for defending the following: (1) A theory that objects endure through time can coherently claim that material objects are identical to spacetime regions they occupy. (2) None of the family of mereological connections need be taken as primitive. (3) Claims entirely in the language of quantifiers, identity, and mereology can be semantically vague without any ‘vagueness in existence’. There are more options for the metaphysics of objects, spacetime, and mereology than many ordinarily assume.