Assessment of Burned Area Products During the Severe Fire Season in the Xingu River Basin, Brazilian Amazon
Authors:
- Juarez Antonio da Silva JuniorJJJuarez Antonio da Silva Junior
- Admilson da Penha PachecoAPAdmilson da Penha Pacheco
- Antonio Miguel Ruiz-ArmenterosARAntonio Miguel Ruiz-Armenteros
- José Anderson Estefano Silva de SouzaJSJosé Anderson Estefano Silva de Souza
- Leidjane Maria Maciel de OliveiraLOLeidjane Maria Maciel de Oliveira
Open Access
Abstract
This study evaluated the performance of four burned area products (AQ1Km, FireCCIS311, MCD64A1, and VNP64A1) using the reference datasets MapBiomas Fire and the Global Annual Burned Area Map (GABAM) for 2024. The two 30 m reference datasets are generated using different automated classification approaches, including deep learning in MapBiomas Fire and Random Forest in GABAM, allowing the sensitivity of product evaluation to alternative machine-learning-based reference frameworks to be examined. The Xingu River basin is a heterogeneous tropical landscape characterized by extensive forest ecosystems, protected and Indigenous territories, agricultural frontiers, and recurrent fire activity. Accuracy metrics derived from confusion matrices (contingency table metrics) were combined with analyses of burned scar geometry, burned patch size, land use and land cover, low-resolution grid regression, and Kernel Density Estimation (KDE) based on active fire hotspots. Results showed substantial differences among products in their ability to represent burned scars under tropical conditions. FireCCIS311 achieved the best overall performance, presenting the highest Intersection over Union (IoU) values (52.67% against MapBiomas Fire), better geometric coherence, and stronger spatial regression consistency (r2 = 0.88). AQ1Km showed higher sensitivity and a stronger association with active fire hotspots, but also greater commission errors (CE) and spatial overestimation. MCD64A1 and VNP64A1 presented intermediate performance, with higher omission rates, particularly in forested and fragmented areas. All products showed low accuracy for small, burned patches, while performance improved for larger and more continuous scars. The results also highlighted the strong influence of the reference dataset on validation outcomes, with markedly better agreement observed with MapBiomas Fire than with GABAM. These results show that product uncertainty can alter the spatial evidence used to characterize wildfire impacts. Regionally validated and complementary burned area products can therefore provide a more reliable basis for forest fire monitoring, post-fire assessment, and operational fire management in heterogeneous tropical landscapes.Keywords
Funding Information
- University of Jaen
- the Coordination for the Improvement of Higher Education Personnel
- the Department of Cartographic Engineering and Surveying (DECart) and the Graduate Program in Civil Engineering (Water Resources) (PPGEC) at the Federal University of Pernambuco
- the Center for Advanced Studies on Earth Sciences, Energy and Environment (CEACTEMA) at the University of Jaén
- the RNM-282 Research Group of the Junta de Andalucía
This publication has 65 references indexed in Scilit:
- Wildfires and Desertification: The Role of Fire Regime2026
- S2BAVG: A global Sentinel-2 grid for burned area product validationInternational Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation, 2025
- Adjusted ∆NBR Index Thresholds for Forest Fire Severity Mapping: A Study in Central AmazoniaLand Degradation & Development, 2025
- An automatic procedure for mapping burned areas globally using Sentinel-2 and VIIRS/MODIS active fires in Google Earth EngineISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, 2024
- Fires in Pantanal: The link to Agriculture, Conversions in Cerrado, and Hydrological ChangesWetlands, 2024
- Joining forces to fight wildfires: Science and management in a protected area of Pantanal, BrazilEnvironmental Science & Policy, 2024
- Deforestation and fires in the Brazilian Amazon from 2001 to 2020: Impacts on rainfall variability and land surface temperatureJournal of Environmental Management, 2022
- Validation of MCD64A1 and FireCCI51 cropland burned area mapping in UkraineInternational Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation, 2021
- Global burned area mapping from ENVISAT-MERIS and MODIS active fire dataRemote Sensing of Environment, 2015
- Characterizing land-use classes in remote sensing imagery by shape metricsISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, 2012