Suing for Peace in the War Against Mentalism
- 4 June 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Perspectives on Behavior Science
- Vol. 42 (2) , 241-266
Abstract
The antimentalists’ war against mentalism has not vanquished it. To examine why, we focus on two theses—mind as causal and internal—and three standard attacks against mentalism as defined by both theses: 1) mentalism implies dualism; 2) mind is unobservable, which hinders its scientific study; and 3) mentalism is impractical. These salients fail because: 1) if the mind is causal and internal, it must be material; 2) the observable/unobservable distinction is too problematic, with antimentalists equivocal about where to draw that line, with some even embracing publicly unobservable behavior as causally relevant; and 3) mentalism has not been demonstrated to be less practical than antimentalism. For the war on mentalism to succeed, stronger attacks must be devised, both scientific and philosophical. We contemplate some possibilities, while expressing doubts as to the wisdom of continuing the war. Peace may be better than war, and the resulting intellectual commerce may be good for both sides.Keywords
This publication has 74 references indexed in Scilit:
- RELATIONAL LEARNING IN A CONTEXT OF TRANSPOSITION: A REVIEWJournal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 2012
- RETHINKING REINFORCEMENT: ALLOCATION, INDUCTION, AND CONTINGENCYJournal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 2012
- Decoding the Large-Scale Structure of Brain Function by Classifying Mental States Across IndividualsPsychological Science, 2009
- Habituation may contribute to within-session decreases in responding under high-rate schedules of reinforcementLearning & Behavior, 2001
- Evidence for the hierarchical structure of instrumental learningLearning & Behavior, 1990
- A model for stimulus generalization in Pavlovian conditioning.Psychological Review, 1987
- Methods and theories in the experimental analysis of behaviorBehavioral and Brain Sciences, 1984
- A behavioral theory of mind?Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 1984
- Radical behaviorist epistemology.Psychological Bulletin, 1980
- Stimulus generalization: Some predictions from a model of Pavlovian conditioning.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Animal Behavior Processes, 1976