Implementation dosage and depressive symptoms following school-based mindfulness and relaxation: Complier Average Causal Effect estimation in the INSPIRE cluster randomised trial
Authors:
Open Access
- 12 August 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry
- Vol. 35 (12) , 3967-3980
Abstract
Implementation variability is hypothesized to be a key treatment effect modifier of universal, school-based mental health interventions, but the evidence base remains meagre. We used Complier Average Causal Effect (CACE) estimation to determine if dosage variability modified treatment effects of relaxation techniques and mindfulness-based exercises in the INSPIRE cluster randomised trial. Analyses were split by phase of education (mindfulness primary: k = 65 primary schools, N = 3,630 pupils; mindfulness secondary: k = 29 secondary schools, N = 3,708 pupils; relaxation primary: k = 66 primary schools, N = 3,800 pupils; relaxation secondary: k = 26 secondary schools, N = 3,252 pupils) and considered compliance effects at the 50th (moderate) and 75th (high) percentiles in the distribution of intervention dosage (total minutes delivered). Despite null intent to treat findings, we observed compliance effects for both interventions. In primary schools, moderate (320 min) and high (376 min) compliance to relaxation techniques significantly reduced depressive symptoms ( d =-1.52 and d =-1.48, respectively). In secondary schools, moderate (207 min) and high (285 min) compliance to mindfulness-based exercises also significantly reduced depressive symptoms ( d= -1.15 and d =-1.40, respectively). Contrastingly, in primary schools, moderate (325 min) and high (393 min) compliance to mindfulness-based exercises significantly increased depressive symptoms ( d = 0.32 and d = 0.48, respectively). In secondary schools, moderate (180 min) and high (275 min) compliance to relaxation techniques also significantly increased depressive symptoms ( d = 0.67 and d = 0.83, respectively). The effects of universal, school-based mental health interventions promoting relaxation and mindfulness are contingent on the delivery of a minimally effective dose. However, these interventions may not be appropriate in all educational contexts and could result in iatrogenic effects. Trial registration: Trial registration number: ISRCTN16386254. Trial registration date:04/09/2018.Keywords
Funding Information
- Department for Education, UK Government
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- Mainstream and special schools’ use of well‐being programmes: A regional surveyBritish Educational Research Journal, 2023
- Universal, School-Based Social and Emotional Learning Interventions and Their Potential to Improve Students’ Mental Health2023
- School-based Mental Health Interventions Targeting Depression or Anxiety: A Meta-analysis of Rigorous Randomized Controlled Trials for School-aged Children and AdolescentsJournal of Youth and Adolescence, 2022
- A Primer to Latent Profile and Latent Class Analysis2022
- Bounce Back: randomised trial of a brief, school-based group intervention for children with emergent mental health difficultiesEuropean Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 2020
- Can social and emotional learning improve children’s academic progress? Findings from a randomised controlled trial of the Promoting Alternative Thinking Strategies (PATHS) curriculumEuropean Journal of Psychology of Education, 2019
- Using Complier Average Causal Effect Estimation to Determine the Impacts of the Good Behavior Game Preventive Intervention on Teacher ImplementersAdministration and Policy in Mental Health and Mental Health Services Research, 2016
- Studying Program Implementation Is Not Easy but It Is EssentialPrevention Science, 2015
- Can Prevention Classification be Improved by Considering the Function of Prevention?Prevention Science, 2013
- Siblings of individuals with autism spectrum disorders across the life courseMental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities Research Reviews, 2007