Further development of camera‐based estimates of abundance for unmarked animals
Open Access
Abstract
Estimating abundance is a cornerstone of wildlife management, conservation, and research, and a variety of approaches have been developed to meet this need. Camera traps have been used to estimate abundance for decades, with earlier deployments using a mark–recapture framework and requiring uniquely identifiable individuals. Recently, there has been a surge in methods using camera trap data that do not require individual identification, including instantaneous sampling (IS) and space‐to‐event (STE) methods. The IS and STE methods involve randomly deploying cameras to simultaneously take photos at fixed intervals and have the advantages of not requiring estimates of animal movement rate and detection probability and are generally robust to variation in animal movement patterns and space use in contrast to nonrandom camera deployments. We describe three alternative estimators of animal density based on IS and STE methods and demonstrate how each are derived. We examined the performance of IS, STE, and the three alternatives using simulated data for 90 different scenarios representing five population densities, three different grouping behaviors, three assumptions of animal movements and habitat selection, and two levels of sampling effort (i.e., 50 and 130 cameras). We evaluated the accuracy of abundance estimates and assessed bias in four alternative approaches for estimating the SE and CIs. We found all estimators were unbiased when there was no habitat selection or when habitat selection was uncorrelated with viewshed area. However, IS was the only estimator that remained unbiased when habitat selection was related to viewshed area. Nonparametric bootstrapping across cameras was the least biased approach for estimating SEs, and unbiased CIs were obtained via a semi‐parametric approach. Across our scenarios, we found that when densities were >2 individuals/km 2 and when >50 photos with animals were observed, a CV in the abundance estimate <20% was generally achieved with the IS method. Our results emphasize the importance of random placement of cameras, as we show that nonrandom deployments such as placing cameras along roads or game trails, without understanding and accounting for the potential habitat selection, can significantly bias abundance estimates.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Estimating animal density using the Space‐to‐Event model and bootstrap resampling with motion‐triggered camera‐trap dataRemote Sensing in Ecology and Conservation, 2023
- Using space to event modeling to estimate density of multiple species in northeastern WashingtonWildlife Society Bulletin, 2022
- Evaluating unmarked abundance estimators using remote cameras and aerial surveysWildlife Society Bulletin, 2022
- Methodology matters when estimating deer abundance: a global systematic review and recommendations for improvementsThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2022
- Population assessment without individual identification using camera-traps: A comparison of four methodsBasic and Applied Ecology, 2022
- Estimating wolf abundance from camerasEcosphere, 2022
- Estimating Abundance of an Unmarked, Low‐Density Species using CamerasThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2020
- Three novel methods to estimate abundance of unmarked animals using remote camerasEcosphere, 2018
- Network Performance Analysis2011
- Estimating tiger Panthera tigris populations from camera-trap data using capture—recapture modelsBiological Conservation, 1995