Should all capital goods of governments be recognised as assets in financial accounting?
Authors:
- Johan ChristiaensJCJohan Christiaens
- Jan RommelJRJan Rommel
- Allan BartonABAllan Barton
- Patricia EveraertPatricia Everaert
- 19 October 2012
- journal article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Baltic Journal of Management
- Vol. 7 (4) , 429-443
Abstract
Purpose: In recent years, accrual accounting has become increasingly popular in many governments. Yet some questions remain unresolved. Previous literature questioned whether all governmental assets should be capitalized. Whereas those studies mostly focussed separately on a limited number of assets, such as infrastructure, military assets or heritage assets, the purpose of this paper is to expand these views by taking a holistic approach to their treatment.Design/methodology/approach: The paper is based on a literature review combined with archival data, being the IPSAS (International Public Sector Accounting Standards).Findings: The analysis distinguishes between the business and government sectors of the economy and argues that business accounting for assets cannot be applied to the public sector without significant modification. Secondly, within the public sector, it is argued that “businesslike assets” (such as normal buildings and equipment) should be distinguished from “specific governmental assets” (such as art galleries), where the latter should be reported off balance sheet as community assets held in trust by governments for community enjoyment.Practical implications: The current paper presents a solution for recognizing capital assets in different situations.Originality/value: The paper reveals some basic differences in points of view between the governmental dimension versus a businesslike dimension in considering capital assets.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- THE DIVERSITY OF ACCRUAL POLICIES IN LOCAL GOVERNMENT FINANCIAL REPORTING: AN EXAMINATION OF INFRASTRUCTURE, ART AND HERITAGE ASSETS IN GERMANY, ITALY AND THE UKFinancial Accountability & Management, 2011
- ACCRUAL ACCOUNTING REFORMS: ONLY FOR BUSINESSLIKE (PARTS OF) GOVERNMENTSFinancial Accountability & Management, 2008
- How to Profit From Defence: A Study in the Misapplication of Business Accounting to the Public Sector in AustraliaFinancial Accountability & Management, 2004
- Public‐Sector Accounting:A Common Reporting Framework? A RejoinderAustralian Accounting Review, 2002
- Options for Infrastructure ReportingAbacus, 2000
- Public and Private Sector Accounting ‐ The Non‐identical TwinsAustralian Accounting Review, 1999
- A Trusteeship Theory of Accounting for Natural Capital AssetsAbacus, 1999
- Land Under Roads - A Financial Bonanza OR Fool's Gold?Australian Accounting Review, 1999
- Governmental accounting for heritage assets: economic, social implicationsInternational Journal of Social Economics, 1997
- The Financial Value Of Cultural, Heritage And Scientific Collections: An Accounting FictionAustralian Accounting Review, 1995