Blame Games and Climate Change: Accountability, Multi-Level Governance and Carbon Management
- 19 March 2014
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in The British Journal of Politics and International Relations
- Vol. 17 (1) , 64-88
Abstract
Research Highlights and Abstract This article provides the first detailed and evidence-based account of the coalition government's approach to transport-related carbon management. It exposes the existence of a ‘governance vacuum’ between the statutory target and a very weak devolved implementation system (i.e. ‘fuzzy governance’ and ‘fuzzy accountability’). Research in four major city regions reveals a systemic switch from an emphasis on carbon management and reduction towards economic growth and job creation. Officials within the policy design and delivery chain emphasise the manner in which the demands of democratic politics tend to frustrate meaningful policy change. A general demand by actors at the local level not for the discretions delivered by localism but for a more robust and centrally managed—even statutory—governance framework. The Climate Change Act 2008 received global acclaim for embedding an ambitious set of targets for the reduction of carbon emissions in legislation. This article explores the policies and institutional frameworks in place to deliver transport-related carbon reductions as part of the subsequent Carbon Plan. A detailed methodology involving institutional mapping, interviews and focus groups combined with a theoretical approach that combines the theory of multi-level governance with the literature on ‘blame avoidance’ serves to reveal a complex system of ‘fuzzy governance’ and ‘fuzzy accountability’. Put simply, it reveals there are no practical sub-national implementation levers for achieving the statutory targets. Apart from symbolic or rhetorical commitments, the emphasis of policy-makers at all levels in the delivery chain has switched from carbon management and reduction to economic growth and job creation. This raises fresh research questions about the pathologies of democratic competition and future responses to the climate change challenge.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Delegation and Institutional Design in Health‐Care RationingGovernance, 2011
- Move Over DanielAdministration & Society, 2011
- The governance of transport and climate changeJournal of Transport Geography, 2010
- Accountability and Multi-level Governance: More Accountability, Less Democracy?West European Politics, 2010
- Does public policy support or undermine climate change adaptation? Exploring policy interplay across different scales of governanceGlobal Environmental Change, 2008
- Holding (Quasi‐)Autonomous EU Administrative Actors to Public AccountEuropean Law Journal, 2007
- Pathologies of Accountability: ICANN and the Challenge of “Multiple Accountabilities Disorder”Public Administration Review, 2005
- National Environmental Ministries: Managers or Ciphers of European Union Environmental Policy?Public Administration, 2001
- From Claiming Credit to Avoiding Blame: The Evolution of Congressional Strategy for Asbestos ManagementJournal of Public Policy, 1991
- The Politics of Blame AvoidanceJournal of Public Policy, 1986