Abstract
Background: Clinical trials demonstrated high efficacy of daily and event-driven oral pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) in HIV prevention. Event-driven PrEP involves taking two tablets before and two times one tablet after sexual contact (2-1-1/on-demand). While both are implemented in Dutch clinical practice, evaluating real-world effectiveness requires large-scale data from routine clinical care. This study compared HIV incidence between daily and event-driven PrEP in the Netherlands.Methods: We used surveillance data from the Dutch national PrEP program (August 1, 2019-December 31, 2025). Individuals ≥16 years with ≥1 follow-up consultation after PrEP initiation were included; PrEP regimen since last visit was recorded at each visit. Person-time was modeled as time-varying based on the regimen reported at each consultation. HIV incidence rates were calculated per 100 person-years and Cox proportional hazards models estimated hazard ratios between regimens for HIV acquisition, adjusted for sociodemographics, sexual behavior, and history of sexually transmissible infections.Findings: 16,469 individuals (15,843 men who have sex with men, 579 transgender and gender diverse persons, 45 women and two men who have sex with women) initiated PrEP and had ≥1 follow-up visit (median follow-up 2·0 years (IQR=0·8-4·0)). Median age was 33 years (IQR=27-44). 49 PrEP users were diagnosed with HIV over 41,092 person-years (IR=0·12/100 py;95%CI=0·09-0·16), of whom 42 event-driven users (IR=0·20/100 py;95%CI=0·15-0·27) and seven daily PrEP users (IR=0·04/100 py;95%CI=0·02-0·07). In multivariable Cox regression, event-driven PrEP use was associated with a higher hazard of HIV acquisition (aHR=7·0;95%CI=3·0-16·4).Interpretation: Despite overall low HIV incidence, the incidence rate in the Dutch national PrEP program was seven-fold higher during event-driven PrEP use compared to daily, which may be due to lower adherence. These findings denotes that, in real-world settings, improved person-centered counseling is needed for individuals interested in, or using event-driven PrEP. Research should identify domains and preferred methods of support.