Assessing invasion risks using EICAT-based expert elicitation: application to a conservation translocation
Authors:
Open Access
- 29 May 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Biological Invasions
- Vol. 26 (8) , 2707-2721
Abstract
Conservation translocations are widely used to recover threatened species, but can pose risks to recipient ecosystems, particularly in the case of conservation introductions. Because of limited data and uncertainty, risk assessments for such projects often rely on extrapolated evidence and expert opinion, further complicating decision making. The Environmental Impact Classification for Alien Taxa (EICAT) serves to classify the realised impacts of invasive species. We developed a protocol combining EICAT and formal expert elicitation to predict these impacts. We applied our protocol to the extinct-in-the-wild sihek (Guam kingfisher; Todiramphus cinnamominus), for which introduction outside the known historical range is being considered. We elicited from multiple experts probability estimates of impact levels across four impact mechanisms and five candidate release sites. We aggregated estimates using simulation-based and Bayesian approaches, with and without accounting for expert confidence. Experts generally agreed that sihek introduction might impact the recipient ecosystem through predation, competition, and disease, although they disagreed about the likely impact levels. Releases to Palmyra Atoll were considered to pose the lowest risk across candidate sites, so this site was selected for further detailed ecological assessments and risk mitigation efforts. EICAT, with its standardized impact mechanisms and definitions, helped reduce the linguistic uncertainty and subjectivity common to expert-based assessments. Expressing judgments as probabilities allowed us to evaluate uncertainty transparently and to assess the weight of expert confidence on the overall risk estimation. Formal quantitative elicitation and aggregation then allowed a transparent evaluation of results, facilitating communication with stakeholders and decision-makers.Keywords
Funding Information
- U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (F16AF01007)
- University of Bern
This publication has 52 references indexed in Scilit:
- Impact assessment of coastal marine range shifts to support proactive managementFrontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 2021
- Quantifying the potential impact of alien plants of Iran using the Generic Impact Scoring System (GISS) and Environmental Impact Classification for Alien Taxa (EICAT)Biological Invasions, 2021
- Options for reducing uncertainty in impact classification for alien speciesEcosphere, 2021
- Recent Advances in the Elicitation of Uncertainty Distributions from Experts for Multinomial Probabilities2021
- Gastropods alien to South Africa cause severe environmental harm in their global alien ranges across habitatsEcology and Evolution, 2018
- Beyond protocols: improving the reliability of expert-based risk analysis underpinning invasive species policiesBiological Invasions, 2017
- Adaptive management for improving species conservation across the captive-wild spectrumBiological Conservation, 2016
- Generating beta random numbers and Dirichlet random vectors in R: The package rBeta2009Computational Statistics & Data Analysis, 2014
- A Bayesian network approach for selecting translocation sites for endangered island birdsBiological Conservation, 2012
- ggplot2WIREs Computational Statistics, 2011