Re-Visiting the New Orthodoxy of Policy Dynamics: The Dependent Variable and Re-Aggregation Problems in the Study of Policy Change
Open Access
- 10 August 2007
- journal article
- Published by University of Northern British Columbia in Canadian Political Science Review
- Vol. 1 (2) , 50-62
Abstract
The new orthodoxy in studies of policy dynamics, including those of Baumgartner and Jones, Sabatier and Jenkins-Smith, and Hall, is that policy change occurs through a homeostatic process. “Perturbations” occurring outside of an institutionalized policy subsystem, often characterized as some type of societal or political upheaval or learning, are critical for explaining the development of profound and durable policy changes which are otherwise limited by ‘endogenous’ institutional stability. These homeostatic assumptions, while useful for assessing many cases of policy change do not adequately capture the historical patterns of policy development found in many sectors. The roots of this problem are traced back to the origins of the new orthodoxy in comparative policy research whereby different levels (orders) of policy-making have been incorrectly juxtaposed, providing a parsimonious, but sometimes empirically incorrect, view of policy change. Revising existing taxonomies of policy levels provides a superior identification of the processes of change, and uncovers more than one mechanism through which significant policy change can occur. Three of these alternative mechanisms - a “neo-homeostatic” one in which paradigmatic changes occur through endogenous shifts in goals; a ‘quasi-homeostatic’ in which exogenous factors influence changes in objectives and settings; and a ‘thermostatic’ one in which durable policy objectives require that settings adapt to exogenous changes - are discussed.Keywords
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- Understanding the historical turn in the policy sciences: A critique of stochastic, narrative, path dependency and process-sequencing models of policy-making over timePolicy Sciences, 2006
- To Trust an Adversary: Integrating Rational and Psychological Models of Collaborative PolicymakingAmerican Political Science Review, 2005
- Privatizing Risk without Privatizing the Welfare State: The Hidden Politics of Social Policy Retrenchment in the United StatesAmerican Political Science Review, 2004
- Policy learning in Swiss research policy—the case of the National Centres of Competence in ResearchResearch Policy, 2003
- The Divided Welfare State2002
- Do Networks Matter? Linking Policy Network Structure to Policy Outcomes: Evidence from Four Canadian Policy Sectors 1990-2000Canadian Journal of Political Science, 2002
- Paradigm Shifts and Policy Networks: Cumulative Change in AgricultureJournal of Public Policy, 1996
- What is Lesson-Drawing?Journal of Public Policy, 1991
- An advocacy coalition framework of policy change and the role of policy-oriented learning thereinPolicy Sciences, 1988
- Punctuated equilibria: the tempo and mode of evolution reconsideredPaleobiology, 1977