Glyphosate Effect: Has the Glyphosate Controversy Affected the EU’s Regulatory Epistemology?
Open Access
- 20 March 2020
- journal article
- conference paper
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in European Journal of Risk Regulation
- Vol. 11 (3) , 422-435
Abstract
Glyphosate’s authorisation will expire in 2022 and its re-approval will take place in a changed legal and political landscape: the national phase of risk assessment is entrusted to a taskforce of four Member States, and, from 2021, the reform of the general food law will apply, imposing,inter alia, more ambitious transparency standards. Taking stock of these developments, this contribution analyses, from a legal perspective, whether and how the glyphosate dispute has contributed to the development of the EU’s regulatory epistemology, with specific regard to food governance. It identifies the “manifesto” of the EU’s regulatory epistemology in the 2002 guidelines on the collection and use of expertise and reads them in the light of the glyphosate dispute. In particular, it focuses on the legal arrangements reflecting the principles established in the 2002 guidelines (quality, openness, effectiveness) and analyses them against the tensions that emerged throughout the dispute with regard to the sources, levels and purposes of EU regulatory knowledge-making. It then considers whether and how such tensions have been addressed by legislative reform and whether this has resulted in a further refinement of the EU’s regulatory epistemology.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- The General Court Orders Disclosure of Glyphosate-related Scientific Studies: Tweedale, Hautala, and the Concept of Environmental Information in the Context of Plant Protection ProductsEuropean Journal of Risk Regulation, 2019
- The Chemical Anthropocene: Glyphosate as a Case Study of Pesticide ExposuresKing's Law Journal, 2019
- The glyphosate saga and the fading democratic legitimacy of European Union risk regulationMaastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law, 2018
- Who owns the information held by EU agencies? Weed killers, commercially sensitive information and transparent and participatory governanceCommon Market Law Review, 2017
- Pesticide Policy and Politics in the European Union2017
- Globalfood safety standards2015
- Cynical or Deliberative? An Analysis of the European Commission’s Public Communication on Its Use of Expertise in Policy-MakingPolitics and Governance, 2015
- Framing Risk Regulation : A Critical ReflectionEuropean Journal of Risk Regulation, 2013
- Why separate risk assessors and risk managers? Further external values affecting the risk assessor qua risk assessorJournal of Risk Research, 2010
- Science and Power in Global Food Regulation: The Rise of the Codex AlimentariusScience, Technology, & Human Values, 2009