Representational Veracity in Data Science Health Research: Targets, Proxies, Labels, and Descriptors
Authors:
- Clement AdebamowoCAClement Adebamowo
- Sally N AdebamowoSASally N Adebamowo
- Adeola AkintolaAAAdeola Akintola
- Peter IkhanePIPeter Ikhane
- Simisola AkintolaSASimisola Akintola
- Temidayo OgundiranTOTemidayo Ogundiran
- Ayodele JegedeAJAyodele Jegede
- Olusegun AdeyemoOAOlusegun Adeyemo
- Shawneequa CallierSCShawneequa Callier
- Muhammad K Imam-TamimMIMuhammad K Imam-Tamim
- Ibrahim UthmanIUIbrahim Uthman
Open Access
- 2 September 2026
- journal article
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in Journal of Medical Internet Research
- Vol. 28, e102537
Abstract
Prevailing ethical oversight of data science health research concentrates on privacy, consent, bias, and fairness. These concerns are necessary but insufficient, because each presupposes an answer to a prior question that is seldom asked directly. That is, “do the targets, proxies, labels, classifications, ontologies, and population descriptors on which a current study rests still truthfully represent the persons, populations, and phenomena they are taken to describe, at the point of use rather than the point of collection?” In this viewpoint, we name that question representational veracity (RV) and develop it as a construct for upstream ethical review. Our aims are to define RV and derive the domains along which it can be assessed; to demonstrate that it asks something that measurement validity, critical data studies, and algorithmic fairness do not; and to translate it into instruments that review bodies can use. We derive 4 assessment domains of RV analytically, asking for each transition in the data journey what must remain stable for a stored artifact still to stand for what it originally stood for. The resulting domains are material provenance, informational descriptors, normative authorization, and relational community. These domains interact but do not substitute for one another. Intact provenance cannot repair a poorly chosen target, and a transparent labeling process cannot confer authorization it never had. Drawing on scholarship in quantification, classification, measurement, critical data studies, algorithmic fairness, and health AI governance, we show that a model may be accurate, reproducible, and formally fair while resting on a representation that is too thin, too unstable, or too normatively misdirected for the proposed use. We examine 4 recurrent failure modes, proxy substitution, category misassignment, label generation error, and descriptor sedimentation, anchoring each in a published case, and we present a counterpoint in which better representation reveals rather than conceals inequity. A polygenic risk score (PRS) case study illustrates all 4 domains and shows how a score can misclassify risk in the populations least represented in its derivation while its code, pipeline, and internal validation statistics remain intact. We then translate the framework into practice using 10 reviewer prompts that an editor can paste into a review form, a justification template and scoring rubric provided as appendices, a tiered model that triggers full review only for subgroup, equity, transportability, public health, or clinical implementation claims, and a graded account of what should follow an adverse finding. Our argument is that existing governance mechanisms require an upstream layer. Investigators should be asked to justify not only whether their models perform, but whether their representations are truthful enough for the claims at hand. The intended audience is investigators, informaticians, research ethics committees, institutional review boards, data access committees, funders, regulators, and journal editors.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 61 references indexed in Scilit:
- Recommendations for responsible use of population descriptors in polygenic risk score developmentNature Genetics, 2025
- Community and bioethicists’ perspectives on iPSC research with biobanked samples collected using broad consentStem Cell Reports, 2025
- Sociodemographic bias in clinical machine learning models: a scoping review of algorithmic bias instances and mechanismsJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2024
- Guiding Principles to Address the Impact of Algorithm Bias on Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health and Health CareJAMA Network Open, 2023
- Algorithmic Fairness and the Situated Dynamics of JusticeCanadian Journal of Philosophy, 2021
- An algorithmic approach to reducing unexplained pain disparities in underserved populationsNature Medicine, 2021
- Reporting guidelines for clinical trial reports for interventions involving artificial intelligence: the CONSORT-AI extensionNature Medicine, 2020
- Hidden in Plain Sight — Reconsidering the Use of Race Correction in Clinical AlgorithmsNew England Journal of Medicine, 2020
- Do no harm: a roadmap for responsible machine learning for health careNature Medicine, 2019
- Clinical use of current polygenic risk scores may exacerbate health disparitiesNature Genetics, 2019